The top reported proficiency rate is 60% in Social studies. The lowest is 40% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Rutherford Elementary
Rutherford Elementary is a regular public school in Gibson County, Tennessee, serving students from pre-kindergarten through eighth grade. It is part of the Gibson County Special School District. The school, located in the small rural town of Rutherford, is a neighborhood school that provides the bulk of a child's public education through middle school. High school students then attend a consolidated campus, Gibson County High School, located a distance away just south of Dyer.
The student body is predominantly white, with a small share of Black students and a smaller share of students identifying as Hispanic, Asian, or of two or more races. Data on the share of students who qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, who receive special education services, and who are English learners were not available, so a family that wants to understand the economic or special-education landscape would need to ask the school directly.
Academically, the school shows a pattern of stronger performance in math and science relative to its own results in English language arts. On state assessments, a majority of students met or exceeded the proficiency bar in math, and roughly half did so in science. Performance in English language arts was lower, with fewer than half of students reaching that benchmark. Social studies results, tested on a smaller group of students, were the strongest of the four subject areas, with a majority of students scoring proficient or above. Overall, when combining all tested subjects and grades, the school's proficiency index places it in the top quartile relative to other districts in Gibson County, a position that reflects genuine strength in these core subjects.
The school participates in the Tennessee state assessment program with extremely high participation rates, meaning the results are a comprehensive picture of student achievement. No data was available on chronic absenteeism or the four-year graduation rate, the latter because the school does not serve high school grades.
The community of Rutherford is a very small, rural, car-dependent town. Its population has been relatively stable to slightly declining, and it has a modest Main Street commercial core anchored by a historic department store. The town leans heavily on its Davy Crockett heritage as a civic and tourist draw. The housing market reflects the rural setting, with home values well below state and national medians. The town has no major employer within its limits, and residents likely commute to nearby larger towns such as Trenton or Humboldt for work.
A parent-relevant change in the district involves a sales tax increase in the town of Medina, one of the towns the district serves. The revenue from this increase benefits district schools. Additionally, a state law enacted in 2023 requiring third-grade students to demonstrate reading proficiency on the state test to avoid retention applies to all Tennessee districts, including Gibson County Special School District; families with young children entering this grade level will want to understand this policy's implications.
Rutherford Elementary's profile fits a family looking for a small-town, rural public elementary and middle school where the academic results, particularly in math, science, and social studies, are on stronger ground compared to many of the other district-level peers in Gibson County. The lower English language arts proficiency rate is a soft spot a parent may want to look into further with the school, particularly given the state's third-grade retention law tied to reading performance. The school is a single point of entry through grade eight, after which students leave the town for a consolidated high school, a transition that is worth factoring into a longer-term housing and schooling decision.
See more original research from School Decision →