The top reported proficiency rate is 54% in English language arts. The lowest is 21% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Mccarroll Middle
McCarroll Middle in Decatur serves sixth through eighth grade and enrolled a mid-sized cohort of students as of the most recent school year. The student body is majority white with a substantial Hispanic enrollment; close to half the school's students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, marking moderate economic need across the population.
On state assessments, McCarroll shows a split picture. English language arts is a strength. Sixth and seventh graders reach proficiency at solid rates, and eighth grade pushes higher still, with a majority meeting state standards. Reading and writing appear to be working. Math tells a harder story. Proficiency in sixth grade is quite low, rising only modestly in seventh grade before improving substantially by eighth grade, where a majority of students meet the standard. This suggests that younger students arrive with significant gaps in mathematical foundational work, though the school does help students progress as they move through the grades. Science proficiency in eighth grade sits around the midpoint. Social studies, tested only in eighth grade, shows a concerning pattern: most students approach the standard but very few actually meet it, indicating that while students are engaging with the material, deeper mastery of history and civics lags noticeably.
Across all subjects, the school's overall proficiency index places it above the midpoint among the seven districts in Wise County, a position that reflects solid ground in ELA balanced against the math and social studies softer spots. The data available does not include prior-year results, so trend direction is not visible; only current-year performance can be assessed.
Decatur, the county seat, is a small city with an active historic downtown courthouse square and a growing residential market as part of the Dallas-Fort Worth expansion corridor. Housing values have risen sharply in recent years, and new construction is active. The school sits on a dispersed campus rather than in the downtown core; Decatur ISD operates six schools across separate locations. The district has experienced significant facility pressure. A long-standing middle school building was approaching capacity, and in May 2026 voters approved a substantial bond that includes a brand-new McCarroll Middle School, replacing the aging campus. This is major infrastructure change that will reshape the building and environment for families enrolling in coming years. The path to this moment mattered: two prior bond measures failed between 2023 and 2024 before the 2026 approval, signaling real community debate and facility stress before resolution. Additionally, the district recently raised its property tax rate, a concrete cost factor for prospective homeowners.
For a family considering McCarroll, the school offers solid performance in language arts and demonstrates growth capacity in math, though students entering sixth grade should be prepared for the proficiency jump expected by eighth grade. Social studies instruction is active but may need supplemental support if depth in civics and history is a priority. The new building coming online represents a capital investment in the school's physical plant and may bring modern facilities, though the current academic picture is what exists now and in the near term before that transition. The growing Decatur community offers residential appeal and proximity to the DFW metroplex, though families should budget for rising property values and understand the district's recent facility and tax changes.
See more original research from School Decision →