The top reported proficiency rate is 67% in Science. The lowest is 22% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Benavides Secondary
Benavides Secondary is a charter middle and high school serving students in sixth through twelfth grade in a small South Texas town shaped by ranching and oil heritage. The school sits within Benavides, a predominantly Hispanic, bilingual community where the town center clusters around its historical rail spine, and where economic life has contracted over decades as oil declined and residents increasingly commuted elsewhere for work.
The school's academic profile reflects both strength and challenge. English language arts proficiency is notably stronger than mathematics. In eighth-grade ELA, about two-thirds of students test at or above proficiency, and across the school about half meet proficiency. Math proficiency lags: only about a quarter of students test proficient in sixth and seventh grades, and just over one-fifth in eighth grade, while about one-third meet the standard across the tested grades. Science results mirror ELA strength, with roughly two-thirds of eighth graders meeting or exceeding proficiency. Social studies proficiency is the school's softest area, with only about one-fifth of eighth graders meeting the standard. Across all tested subjects and grades, the school's overall proficiency index places it in the top quartile among districts in Duval County, though this reflects a county-level comparison and does not change the fact that math and social studies represent genuine instructional gaps a family would want to understand more deeply.
The student body is small, around one hundred and ten students across seven grade levels, with the grade twelve cohort being noticeably larger than the others. About four-fifths of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, and the population is roughly ninety-five percent Hispanic. The school is a regular public charter, not a traditional district school.
Two structural changes affect this school's context. The district recently consolidated its two separate campuses into one building, moving all elementary students onto the secondary campus. Alongside that consolidation, the district put forward a substantial facility bond in May 2025 to fund upgrades to HVAC, plumbing, electrical systems, athletics, and technology. The district noted that property taxes could increase for some owners as a result, though the bond's outcome was not confirmed in available sources. This is a concrete change that shapes where families' younger children will attend school and carries potential tax implications worth verifying with the district directly.
Second, Benavides ISD joined the Rural Schools Innovation Zone in 2023, a five-district South Texas partnership that creates pathways for students to earn college credit, associate degrees, and industry certifications while still in high school. This expands the academic and career options available to students beyond what a small district could offer alone, and publicly reported data shows that the participating districts have outperformed state averages on College, Career and Military Readiness metrics since adopting the model.
The town itself is small and economically stretched. Median home values are low relative to state and national benchmarks, and the population has declined steadily over decades, falling by roughly a third since mid-century. Public-sector employment, including the school district itself, forms a meaningful share of local work. Growth and new housing development are not evident in the area.
State testing data for the high school grades (nine through twelve) was not available in the sources provided, so the school's academic profile rests on middle school results only. Graduation rate, attendance, chronic absenteeism, staffing detail, and course offerings beyond the career and technical pathways mentioned were not provided. A parent weighing this school would benefit from asking the district directly about high school proficiency trends, specific CTE program options, career outcomes for recent graduates, and the timeline and tax impact of the campus consolidation and bond.
See more original research from School Decision →