The top reported proficiency rate is 81% in English language arts. The lowest is 74% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Old Mill School
Old Mill School is an elementary school in Heber City serving preschool through fifth grade, part of the Wasatch County School District. It is a large school for its grade band, with a student body that is predominantly white and includes a notable Hispanic minority. The share of students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch is modest, indicating a relatively more affluent catchment. Data on students with disabilities and English learners was not available in the records reviewed.
Academically, Old Mill stands out. On the state’s RISE assessments, students posted strong proficiency rates in math, English language arts, and science. The school’s overall proficiency index was well above the midpoint when compared with other schools in Wasatch County, placing it among the highest-performing elementary schools in the area. This is a clear strength for families who prioritize demonstrated academic achievement in the early grades. Because the school ends at fifth grade, there are no graduation rate or college readiness measures to report. No information on specialized programs such as gifted, arts, or STEM offerings was found.
Heber City itself is a rapidly growing community. Originally an agricultural center, it has transformed into a mountain-suburb of Salt Lake City, with a strong tourism economy tied to skiing, reservoirs, and outdoor recreation. The city is adding population quickly, and median home values and rents are high, reflecting significant demand and limited housing supply relative to incomes. The area’s commute times are moderate, suggesting a mix of local employment and some commuting. For families moving to the area, the housing market is an important consideration: it is expensive.
At the district level, publicly reported plans include a second comprehensive high school, Deer Creek High School, set to open in August 2026, alongside a new Mountainland Technical College campus. These investments signal the district’s response to growth and its commitment to expanding secondary and career-technical options, though they are more directly relevant to families with older children.
For a family evaluating Old Mill School, the academic results are a strong point. The school also sits in a district that is actively building for the future. The main open questions for a parent touring the school would center on what specialized programs are available and how the school supports students with varied learning needs, since that information was not available in the data. The community context—expensive housing, rapid growth, and a tourism-driven economy—shapes the overall experience for families living here.
See more original research from School Decision →