The top reported proficiency rate is 51% in English language arts. The lowest is 29% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Lothrop School
Lothrop School is a small public elementary school in Pittsford, Vermont, serving pre-kindergarten through sixth grade as part of the Otter Valley Unified Union School District. The town sits along the Otter Creek valley and the Route 7 corridor, between Rutland to the south and Brandon to the north. Working farms, forests, and residential properties define the landscape. Pittsford's own website describes it as "Vermont's Sunshine Village," and the character is predominantly rural and residential rather than commercial.
The school's enrollment is modest, with a student body that is largely white and a substantial share of students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch. Because Lothrop serves only elementary grades, it has no graduation rate, no high school course offerings, and no AP or dual-credit pathways. Those come later, at Otter Valley Union High School in Brandon, which serves multiple towns in the area.
On state assessments, the most recent Vermont Comprehensive Assessment Program results show a mixed picture. In English language arts, Lothrop's fourth and fifth graders performed at or around the midpoint, with roughly half of tested students reaching proficiency. Mathematics results were lower, with under a third of fourth graders and about a quarter of fifth graders demonstrating proficiency. Fifth grade science results fell in a similar range to math. Third and sixth grade results were suppressed, which in a school this size often reflects small testing populations and should not be read as a signal of weak performance.
The pattern is one where reading and writing outcomes are meaningfully stronger than math and science outcomes. A parent weighing this school may want to look into how the school approaches math instruction and what intervention or enrichment is available for students who need additional support.
Pittsford itself is stable and slow-growing, with publicly available sources noting a modest population decline over recent years. No major new housing developments or growth initiatives surfaced in the available material. The housing market here is more affordable than both the Vermont state benchmark and the national benchmark, with typical home values sitting below those wider measures. For a family evaluating the area, that relative affordability matters.
Civic life in Pittsford centers on a handful of anchors. The Maclure Library serves as a community gathering place. The town's annual meeting is held in the Lothrop School gymnasium, which positions the school as more than an academic building. It is a civic space where residents gather to conduct town business. The town maintains walking trails and a recreation area. Route 7 is the main artery, connecting residents to Rutland for larger commercial and medical services.
Several data gaps are worth naming. Information on individualized education programs, English learner services, staffing ratios, chronic absenteeism, discipline data, and course access was not available in the provided data. The neighbor comparison, which would position this school against others in Rutland County, could not be computed because the cohort was too small and certain values were missing. A parent seeking those specifics should ask the school or district directly.
What Lothrop offers is a small, community-anchored elementary education in a rural Vermont setting, with stronger reading results than math results, housing that is affordable relative to state and national levels, and a town where the school building itself functions as a civic hub.
See more original research from School Decision →