The top reported proficiency rate is 66% in English language arts. The lowest is 39% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Waterford Elementary School
Waterford Elementary School sits on Duck Pond Road in a small, rural Vermont town in Caledonia County's Northeast Kingdom. It is a pre-kindergarten through eighth-grade school, part of the Caledonia Cooperative Unified School District, serving the children of Waterford and drawing from a community spread across historic villages and farmland. The town is low-density and automobile-dependent, with civic life anchored in the White Village of Lower Waterford, where the library, town office, post office, church, and the Rabbit Hill Inn cluster among eighteenth-century structures. Waterford holds the highest per capita income of any town or city in the Northeast Kingdom, though the local employment base is limited to farming, construction, quarries, and small-scale lodging. Publicly reported sources describe the town as stable and low-growth, shaped historically by the construction of Moore Dam, which submerged the old village of Upper Waterford and shifted the town center to Lower Waterford.
The school is small, with roughly a dozen to two dozen students per grade. This is the kind of enrollment where one or two children moving in or out can shift a grade's results, and parents reading the state assessment data should keep that volatility in mind. The student body is predominantly white, with a small number of students identifying as Black, Hispanic, or two or more races. About half of the students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. Data on individualized education programs and English learner status was not available, so those dimensions of student support cannot be characterized here.
On Vermont's Comprehensive Assessment Program, the most recent results show a clear pattern. English language arts is the school's stronger subject, particularly in the earlier grades, where most third, fourth, and fifth graders reached proficiency. Those results tapered in the middle grades, with sixth and eighth grade showing weaker performance, though seventh grade rebounded. Math tells a different story. Proficiency was modest in third and fourth grade, rose to a relative high point in fifth grade, then dropped sharply in sixth, seventh, and eighth. Science was assessed only in fifth and eighth grade, with the younger group performing well and the older group struggling. The school does not serve high school grades, so there is no graduation rate to report. This is expected given the grade band. No multi-year trend data was available, and participation rates were missing from the state data, so it is not possible to say how complete the testing picture is. A parent may want to ask the school directly about participation and about what supports are in place for the middle-grade math dip, since that is where the results are softest.
The comparison fact-set, which positions this school relative to districts in Caledonia County, could not produce proficiency, graduation, or chronic absenteeism comparisons. The county cohort was too small to support a proficiency index, and the school's graduation and attendance figures are absent. This means there is no peer benchmark in the data to set Waterford against, only the raw state results.
For families thinking about housing, the local market is more affordable than the Vermont state benchmark and below the national one. The price-to-income ratio sits below four, which is relatively moderate for a New England town, and mortgage rates used in the affordability calculation reflect the current high-rate environment. Rental data was not available, so renters would need to look elsewhere for guidance. The town's stable, low-growth character means the housing market is unlikely to move quickly, for better or worse.
After eighth grade, Waterford does not have its own high school. The town operates under Vermont's Public High School Choice framework, meaning families apply to send their children to schools elsewhere. Nearby options include St. Johnsbury Academy, Lyndon Institute, Concord School, and Danville School. This is a defining feature of the educational pathway here: elementary and middle school are local and village-centered, but high school requires a deliberate choice and a commute.
We looked for recent district-level changes that would matter to parents, but publicly available sources turned up little of lasting impact, so nothing specific can be reported. The district brief did not surface strategic priorities, program expansions, or restructuring that would change the picture for families currently considering the school.
See more original research from School Decision →