The top reported proficiency rate is 66% in Math. The lowest is 54% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on First Branch Middle School
First Branch Middle School sits on School Street in Chelsea, Vermont, serving grades five through eight as part of the First Branch Unified School District. It is a small rural middle school by any measure, with an enrollment that fills only a handful of classrooms. The student body is nearly entirely white, and about half of the students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The school is not a charter or magnet, and no Title I status was reported in the data we received.
State testing results from the most recent year tell a mixed but partially encouraging story, though the picture is incomplete. Fifth-grade and eighth-grade results in math, English language arts, and science were all suppressed, which often reflects very small testing cohorts in rural Vermont schools where privacy rules kick in. For the grades where results were reported, seventh grade stands out as a clear strength. Seventh-graders posted strong proficiency in both math and ELA, with the math result being particularly high. Sixth-grade results were more modest, with ELA proficiency landing below half the class and math proficiency just above the midpoint. A parent looking at these numbers should keep in mind that each grade cohort here is small enough that a few students moving in either direction can shift the results noticeably from year to year. We looked for multi-year trend data and found none available, so there is no way to tell from the provided data whether these results represent a consistent pattern or year-to-year fluctuation.
The school does not have a graduation rate, which is expected because it serves only middle school grades. No data on chronic absenteeism, discipline, course access, staffing ratios, or IEP and English learner populations was available in the materials we received. These are gaps a parent may want to ask the school about directly, particularly around special education services and attendance patterns, since neither was reported here.
We also looked for a comparison placing this school against others in Orange County, but the comparison set came back inapplicable because the cohort of comparable schools was too small. So there is no neighbor benchmark to set against these results. The school's own district-level context might help frame it, but no district brief was provided.
On the housing side, Chelsea sits in a part of Orange County where home values run below both the Vermont state benchmark and the national one. The typical home value in the school's zip code is well under the state figure, and the price-to-income ratio sits in a range that suggests a degree of relative affordability compared with much of the state, though current mortgage rates make the monthly cost real for working families. No rental data was available for this location. The broader economic picture shows a national unemployment rate holding steady, and median household income has been rising gradually in real terms over the past several years.
What the assembled data suggests is a very small, homogeneous rural middle school where seventh-grade academic performance is a bright spot, sixth-grade results are softer and may warrant a closer look, and several grades' results are simply unavailable due to small numbers. Families considering this school should weigh the intimacy of a small cohort, where children are known individually, against the reality that small cohorts produce volatile data and limited program information. The strongest move a parent can make here is to visit the school, ask about how the school supports students who are not yet proficient in sixth-grade ELA, and request the attendance and special-education figures that did not appear in the available data.
See more original research from School Decision →