The top reported proficiency rate is 100% in Social studies. The lowest is 53% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Butternut Elementary
Butternut Elementary is a regular public school in the village of Butternut, serving students from pre-kindergarten through fifth grade. It is the only elementary school in the Butternut School District, a very small rural district in Ashland County, deep in the northern Wisconsin lake country. The village itself is car-dependent, home to about as many people as a mid-sized neighborhood, and its identity revolves around outdoor recreation — Butternut Lake, the North Fork of the Flambeau River, and nearby trails draw tourists and support a handful of resorts, guide services, and small merchants. Manufacturing employs the largest share of workers, and median household income and property values are both low by state standards. The population has declined over the past couple of decades, and no major new housing or commercial development has been publicly reported.
The student body is small and demographically homogeneous. Nearly all students are white, with a very small number of Hispanic students and a handful identifying as two or more races. About three of every five students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, a share that points to a community where economic strain is common. The school does not report the share of students receiving special education services or English learner supports, so those profiles are not available from the data.
On state assessments, Butternut Elementary’s overall proficiency, when averaged across tested grades and subjects, places it well above the midpoint among the four districts in Ashland County. That is a strong result for a school this size. Yet the picture is uneven when you look grade by grade. In third grade, about three-quarters of students met or exceeded expectations in both math and English language arts, and all students participated. Fourth graders, a very small group, posted perfect proficiency in English language arts and social studies, and all but one were proficient in science; math in fourth grade was closer to the middle of the range, with a bit more than half reaching the bar. Fifth grade is where the numbers soften sharply: fewer than one in four were proficient in math, and fewer than half in English language arts. The drop-off is notable, though the tested group was larger than the other grades. A parent may want to discuss with the school how the curriculum or support structures shift as students approach the middle school transition.
Because Butternut Elementary serves only early grades, there is no high school graduation rate or college-readiness data to consider. State testing participation was complete across all reported grades, which keeps the results reliable.
The district itself appears stable at a basic level. No recent referendums, curriculum overhauls, or other changes that would materially affect a family’s day-to-day experience were found in publicly reported sources. The village website references an award-winning school, which aligns with the strong relative proficiency, but specific program offerings — such as art, music, physical education, or extended learning — are not documented in the available data.
For a family considering this community, Butternut Elementary offers a very small, rural setting where academic performance in the early grades compares favorably with other schools in the same county. The economic backdrop is modest, the housing market is affordable, and the natural environment is a clear draw. A family should expect that fifth-grade results may indicate a need for closer attention to how students are prepared for the middle grades, and that the school’s size means limited course variety and fewer peers per grade. The school fits families who value a tight-knit rural school with strong early-grade outcomes and are comfortable with a community that is stable but not growing.
See more original research from School Decision →