The top reported proficiency rate is 67% in Social studies. The lowest is 47% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Plum City Middle School
Plum City Middle School serves grades six through eight in the small, rural village of Plum City in western Wisconsin. It is a regular public school within the Plum City School District, a district that covers a very compact village and the surrounding countryside. For a family considering this school, the most immediate context is size: this is a small school in a very small community, and the academic picture that emerges from state testing reflects both strengths and areas where a parent may want to learn more.
State assessment results from the most recent testing year, which covers the Wisconsin Forward exam, show that proficiency rates vary noticeably by subject and grade level. In mathematics, the share of students scoring proficient or above ranged from a moderate level in seventh grade to a lower level in eighth grade. In English language arts, sixth graders performed at a higher level than their schoolmates in seventh and eighth grades, with the eighth-grade cohort showing a lower rate. Science results for eighth graders were in a similar range, while social studies proficiency was higher, reaching a rate that stands out as the strongest single subject result for the school. When placed next to the four other middle-level schools in Pierce County districts, the school’s overall proficiency index falls in the bottom quartile. That comparison is worth noting, but the small size of each grade cohort means that a few students’ results can shift the picture meaningfully from year to year; a parent might ask the school for trend data across multiple years to see whether these results are stable or changing.
Enrollment and student demographic information, including counts of students by race and ethnicity, economic disadvantage, special education status, and English learner status, was not available in the data we reviewed. That gap makes it difficult to describe the peer environment precisely. Families often want to know the share of students who qualify for free or reduced-price meals, the range of backgrounds in the classroom, and the level of specialized support, but those figures are simply missing here. Because the school is small and rural, and the district’s elementary and high school share the same campus footprint on Main Street, the overall student population of the district is modest, and the middle school likely reflects that.
Plum City itself is a very small village of about a square mile, with a population that has been declining slowly over recent years. The village’s housing values, based on data for the zip code, are well below the Wisconsin state average and somewhat below the national average, making it a relatively affordable market compared to many parts of the state. There are no large employers in town; the school district and village government are among the biggest local institutions. The village is primarily residential, with civic life centered on Main Street, where the schools, village hall, library, and senior center are all located. The setting is rural, and personal vehicles are the main transportation option.
The district that operates this school has made several recent changes that directly affect the middle school. In 2024, voters approved two referendum questions that provide additional recurring and non-recurring funding for programs, class sizes, instructional technology, and facility maintenance. That ongoing revenue increase is a significant shift for a small district. The district also adopted new curriculum materials in recent years: a new elementary literacy curriculum aligned with Wisconsin’s science-based early reading law, new math resources, and new science materials aligned to the Next Generation Science Standards. These curriculum overhauls will have rolled through to the middle school grades, so students currently in the building are learning under recently updated instructional frameworks.
For a family, this is a school that fits a specific profile: a small rural community where the school is integrated into the village’s daily life, where class sizes are naturally small because the overall enrollment is modest, and where recent district investments in curriculum and funding signal that the community is supporting the school through tax measures. The academic profile, as measured by state tests, shows a range with some subjects stronger than others, and overall performance is below the middle of the pack among the county’s districts. A parent who values a close-knit, rural school setting where they can know the teachers and the principal personally may find that fits well here. A parent who is focused on high absolute proficiency rates or broad advanced coursework might want to investigate further, especially since the missing demographic data leaves a partial view of the student body and available supports.
See more original research from School Decision →