The top reported proficiency rate is 56% in Social studies. The lowest is 38% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Shullsburg Elementary
Shullsburg Elementary is a regular public school serving prekindergarten through fifth grade in the small historic city of Shullsburg, in southwestern Wisconsin’s Lafayette County. The school is part of the Shullsburg School District, a single-building district where the elementary shares a site with older grades in a Romanesque limestone structure that dates to the early twentieth century. The enrollment is small and the building sits within the town’s walkable grid, not on a separated campus, so the school feels integrated into daily community life.
The student body is predominantly White, with a notable share of Hispanic students. More than half of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, indicating a moderate-to-high level of economic need. Special-population counts for students with disabilities and English learners were not available in the data, so a parent may want to check directly with the school about those supports.
On state assessments, Shullsburg Elementary’s results are mixed when compared with other districts in Lafayette County. The school’s overall proficiency index across tested subjects and grades falls in the bottom quartile among the county’s seven districts. In third-grade English language arts, about half of students met state proficiency standards, while in fifth-grade ELA the share was lower. Math proficiency varied by grade as well, with fourth grade showing a stronger result than third or fifth. Fourth-grade science and social studies results were around the midpoint, though the tested group was small. Participation rates were high in nearly all subjects. Because the tested grade-level groups are very small, one year’s results can swing more than they would in a larger school; a family looking for sustained academic progress would be wise to ask about trends over multiple years and any support programs the school offers.
The community context is distinctive. Shullsburg is an old lead-mining town that has shifted to dairy and heritage tourism. Its historic Water Street commercial district, with many buildings on the National Register, anchors a compact downtown. Population has been declining slowly over several decades, and the town was named a Wisconsin Main Street Community in recognition of its preservation efforts rather than new growth. Housing values are below state and national benchmarks, making this a relatively affordable market. The school district’s recent publicly reported priorities were sparse, so it is unclear whether there are major initiatives underway; the district appears to be stable with no dramatic changes.
This is a school that suits families who value a small, close-knit setting in a historic rural town with a strong sense of place. The academic results suggest room for growth, particularly in math and upper-grade reading, and a parent interested in strong outcomes should investigate what interventions or enrichment are available. The elementary feeds into Shullsburg’s combined middle and high school, so the full K‑12 pathway is contained in one building. For a family seeking affordable housing, a walkable downtown, and a school where their child will be known by name, Shullsburg Elementary is a reasonable option worth exploring further on the academic side.
See more original research from School Decision →