The top reported proficiency rate is 67% in English language arts. The lowest is 58% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Washington Island Elementary
Washington Island Elementary is the only public school on Washington Island, a rural island community in Door County that is reachable only by ferry or small aircraft. The school serves students from pre-kindergarten through eighth grade, after which families must arrange for high school education on the mainland, typically by commuting or relocating. The school is part of the Washington Island School District, a single-school district that mirrors the island’s small, close-knit character.
The student body is small, and nearly all students are white. The school population is large enough to offer a full pre-K through eighth grade experience, but classes are tiny, with only a handful of students per grade in most years. That scale shapes the entire school experience. Teachers know every student well, and instruction can be highly individualized. It also means that the range of elective courses, extracurricular offerings, and specialized staff found in larger schools is not available here. The school does not serve high school grades, so there is no graduation rate, no advanced placement or dual-credit course data, and no state testing results for the upper grades that would be typical of a comprehensive high school.
State assessment results are available for only a few grade levels and subjects, with many results suppressed due to very small group sizes, a common pattern in a school this size where reporting thresholds cannot be met. For the grades and subjects where data was reported, proficiency rates varied widely. In fifth-grade math, roughly two-thirds of students scored at or above the proficient level. In fifth-grade English language arts and sixth-grade math, about half did. In sixth-grade English language arts, a strong majority of students met the proficiency bar. Because the reported numbers come from very small groups of test-takers, year-to-year swings can be large, and these results should be read as a snapshot rather than a definitive trend. The school’s overall proficiency index, which averages the reported rates across all tested subjects and grades, places it in the bottom quartile relative to other districts in Door County. A parent may want to ask the school how it tracks individual student growth and what academic supports are in place, since the small numbers make annual rating less informative than a broader look at each child’s progress.
Housing on Washington Island is expensive relative to national norms, with home values comparable to many suburban markets in Wisconsin. The island’s economy is driven by tourism, including a lavender farm, ferry services, and seasonal visitors, rather than by a large year-round employer base. The year-round population is modest, and the island has a deep Icelandic heritage. Civic life is concentrated around the Detroit Harbor area and Main Road, where the community center and town offices are located. The built environment is rural and island-based, with biking and the ferry as primary ways of getting around. No information was publicly reported about recent major changes to the school district that would affect families, such as staffing shifts, program additions, or facility upgrades.
For a family considering this school, the central question is whether the school’s small size and island setting match their priorities. The school offers a safe, highly personal educational environment with full parent involvement a near certainty. The trade-offs are limited academic breadth, no on-island high school option, and a level of test-score predictability that is inherently constrained by the small number of students. Families who value a tightly integrated community, outdoor access, and individualized attention may find it a strong fit. Those seeking broad program offerings, robust peer group sizes, or a traditional K-12 pathway with choice of advanced coursework would need to weigh the commute or move required for high school and the school’s limited scale. The school’s academic performance, based on available data, is mixed and variable from year to year, and a direct conversation with the principal about current instructional approaches and student support would be useful for any prospective family.
See more original research from School Decision →