The top reported proficiency rate is 36% in English language arts. The lowest is 18% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Kimball Elementary School
Kimball Elementary School sits along Coal Heritage Road in the small McDowell County town of the same name, serving pre-kindergarten through fifth grade as a regular public school in the McDowell County Schools district. The town of Kimball has deep roots in the coal and railroad economy that once defined southern West Virginia. It functioned for decades as a commercial and residential hub for surrounding coal camps, with a bank, general stores, drug stores, a bowling alley, and a movie theater. Those days are largely gone. The town lost its biggest employers when a Kmart and later a Walmart superstore closed, and the population has been in long-term decline. Today Kimball is rural and residential, with a compact historic core along the main road and a quiet streetscape oriented more toward heritage tourism than daily commerce. The Five Loaves and Two Fishes food bank is a anchor community institution, and the nearby Hatfield McCoy Trail System draws off-road enthusiasts. The town council has voiced goals of revitalization, but no major new housing development was identified.
The school itself is small for its grade band, with enrollment spread fairly evenly across pre-kindergarten through fifth grade. The student body is predominantly white, with a substantial Black minority and a smaller group identifying as two or more races. A handful of students are Asian or Hispanic. Information on free or reduced-price lunch eligibility, individualized education program participation, and English learner status was not available, so the picture of economic need and special populations is incomplete from the data provided.
Academic results come from the West Virginia General Summative Assessment for the 2024-25 school year. Participation was full across every tested grade. The clearest pattern is a decline in proficiency as students move from third grade toward fifth. In both math and English language arts, third graders showed relatively strong results, with roughly half scoring proficient or above. Fourth-grade proficiency dropped to a lower band, and by fifth grade, proficiency fell further in both subjects, with only a small fraction of students reaching proficiency in math. Fifth-grade science results were also low. This downward trajectory across the grade levels is the most striking feature of the available data. Whether it reflects challenges in instruction, student mobility, or broader community factors is something a parent may want to look into directly with the school. State testing was not available for grades six through eight, which is expected given that the school only serves through fifth grade, so those gaps reflect the grade band rather than a missing result.
No multi-year trend data was available beyond the current year, so there is no way to tell from the data whether these results represent a persistent pattern or a single year's snapshot. Average scale scores were also missing from the data set, so proficiency rates are the only academic measure available.
The McDowell County Schools district context offers limited additional guidance. Publicly reported sources reference historical events such as a past state takeover that was later returned to local control and the Reconnecting McDowell initiative, but no lasting parent-relevant changes from recent years surfaced in available sources. We looked for the district's strategic priorities but found little, so we left it out rather than guess.
No program offerings data, staffing information, discipline data, course access data, attendance data, or housing market figures were provided for the school. The school's Title I status and magnet or charter designations were also not available, though the data confirms it is a regular public school, not a charter. Without these pieces, a parent reading this account has only a partial view. What the data does show is a small community school in a town working through decades of economic contraction, with assessment results that start reasonably strong in the early grades but slip as students approach middle school. A parent considering Kimball Elementary would benefit from asking school leaders about their plans for upper-grade instruction, what support services exist given the absence of reported special-population data, and how the school fits into the broader McDowell County approach.
See more original research from School Decision →