The top reported proficiency rate is 52% in English language arts. The lowest is 25% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Brushfork Elementary School
Brushfork Elementary School sits on Brushfork School Road in Bluefield, West Virginia, serving kindergarten through fifth grade as part of Mercer County Schools. It is a regular public school, and its enrollment is modest, with roughly even distribution across the six grade levels. The student body is predominantly white, with smaller groups identifying as two or more races, Black, and Asian, and a very small Hispanic presence. The school does not report free-or-reduced-price lunch data, IEP rates, or English-learner figures in the data we received, so we cannot speak to the economic profile of the families it serves or the share of students receiving special-education services. Those gaps are worth noting, and a parent wanting the full picture may want to ask the school directly.
Bluefield itself is a small Appalachian city in Mercer County, straddling the Virginia border. It grew up as a Norfolk and Western Railway division point and coal-boom town, and it has been losing population for decades as those industries restructured. Publicly reported sources describe a city with a historic downtown commercial district, aging housing stock, and lingering blight from its boom-era expansion. Bluefield State University, a public HBCU, and Bluefield High School are the main institutional anchors. The local economy still leans on railroad and coal, supplemented by food production, wood products, and tourism. Interstate 77 runs nearby, and proposed interstates 73 and 74, labeled the King Coal Highway, are under construction. The housing market around Brushfork is inexpensive by state and national standards, with the typical home value well below the West Virginia benchmark and far below the national figure. Recent values have declined year over year, which reflects the broader population trajectory rather than anything specific to the school.
On state assessments, Brushfork's results tell a mixed but mostly middling story. In math, third graders landed at about half proficient, fourth graders came in slightly above that, and fifth graders dropped to a lower share. English language arts followed a similar pattern, with fourth grade the strongest, third grade in the same midrange, and fifth grade somewhat lower. Science, tested only in fifth grade, was the weakest result, with a quarter of tested students reaching proficiency. Participation was full or near-full across the tested grades, which means the results reflect the enrolled population rather than a skewed subset. No trend data across multiple years was available, so we cannot say whether these numbers represent improvement, decline, or stability. A parent looking at the fifth-grade drop in both math and reading, and the low science result, may want to look into this further with the school to understand whether this reflects a cohort issue, a transition challenge, or something else.
Because Brushfork serves only kindergarten through fifth grade, there are no middle-school or high-school assessment results, no graduation rate, and no college-readiness or career-pathway data. Those metrics do not apply to a school at this grade band. We also did not receive data on discipline, course access, staffing, attendance, or Title I status, so we cannot characterize the school's climate or resources in those areas. The school's Title I status in particular was not reported, which limits the picture for families who use that as a signal of the level of federal support and student need.
What the data does show is a small community elementary school in a city working through long economic transition. Housing is affordable, the setting is rooted in Appalachian geography and railroad history, and the school's academic results are middle-of-the-road in the early grades with a clear softening by fifth grade. For a family already in or drawn to the Bluefield area, Brushfork offers a neighborhood-scale elementary option with steady grade-by-grade enrollment and testing participation. The questions worth bringing to the school directly center on the fifth-grade dip, the science outcome, and the support services and programs that the available data simply does not cover.
See more original research from School Decision →