Original Research by School Decision on St. Marys High School
St. Marys High School sits in Saint Marys, West Virginia, and serves grades nine through twelve as a regular public school in the Pleasants County Schools district. The enrollment is small for a four-year high school, with students spread fairly evenly across the four grade levels. The student body is almost entirely white, with only a handful of students identifying as Black, Hispanic, or two or more races. Data on free or reduced-price lunch eligibility was not available, so the economic profile of the student body cannot be characterized from what we have. Information on students with individualized education programs and English learners was also missing.
State assessment results present a gap that reflects the school's grade band. The West Virginia General Summative Assessment data we received covers grades three through eight in math, English language arts, and science. Because St. Marys High School starts at ninth grade, those tested grades do not apply here, and the proficiency figures for those grade levels are absent for that reason rather than signaling a weak result. The multi-year trend data includes an aggregated "all grades" figure for math and science, but both show proficiency at essentially zero, based on a single year of data with no prior point for comparison. No ELA trend figure was included. These near-zero results are unusual and difficult to interpret from the data alone. A parent may want to ask the school directly how its high school students perform on state assessments, since the picture here is incomplete and the available numbers raise questions worth following up on.
No graduation rate was provided in the data we reviewed. Given that this is a regular high school, a graduation rate would normally be expected, and its absence here is a gap rather than something explained by the school's type or grade range. A parent considering this school should request the current graduation rate and any recent trends directly from the school or district. Similarly, no data on course access, Advanced Placement offerings, career or technical education pathways, dual-credit programs, discipline, attendance, or staffing was available. Without these, it is not possible to characterize the academic program's breadth or the school's climate from the evidence at hand.
Pleasants County Schools, the parent district, had no documented parent-relevant changes in the material we reviewed. The district brief search returned only directory and demographic information, with no evidence of lasting programmatic, leadership, or policy shifts that a family would need to weigh.
On housing, Saint Marys sits in Pleasants County, where typical home values run below the statewide benchmark for West Virginia and well below national figures. The area's price-to-income ratio, based on national median income, sits below two, suggesting that housing here is relatively affordable compared with much of the country, particularly when measured against national home values. Rental data was not available, so the rental market cannot be characterized. The broader economic context includes a national unemployment rate in the low-to-mid four percent range and a thirty-year fixed mortgage rate in the mid-six percent range, both of which shape what a family moving into the area would face in terms of financing a home purchase.
What we can say about St. Marys High School is limited by the data. It is a small, nearly homogeneous rural high school in an affordable housing market within a district that appears stable but unremarkable in the public record. The academic picture, from state testing through graduation, could not be assembled from the available evidence. A family seriously considering this school should plan to visit and ask directly about assessment results, graduation rates, course offerings, and student support services, since those pieces are missing here rather than absent from the school itself.
See more original research from School Decision →