The top reported proficiency rate is 47% in Math. The lowest is 35% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Sistersville Elementary School
Sistersville Elementary School sits in a small, quiet residential town on the Ohio River in Tyler County, West Virginia. The town's identity was shaped by a late-1800s oil boom that briefly swelled its population before it settled into the low-key community it is today. A compact historic downtown along the river, with landmarks like the Wells Inn and the NRHP-listed City Hall, gives Sistersville a distinct small-town character. The Sistersville Ferry, the last operating toll ferry in the state, still carries vehicles and passengers across the Ohio to Fly, Ohio. Publicly reported sources describe a town experiencing modest population decline, with no major new housing developments or growth initiatives on the horizon. Housing here is quite affordable relative to both state and national benchmarks, which may appeal to families looking for a low-cost entry point, though the limited commercial activity means amenities and services are sparse.
The school serves pre-kindergarten through fifth grade and is part of Tyler County Schools, a small rural district. Enrollment is modest for its grade band, and the student body is nearly entirely white, with only a handful of students identifying as Hispanic or of two or more races. This is a homogeneous peer environment, which reflects the broader community composition. The data does not include free-or-reduced-price lunch counts, IEP rates, or English-learner figures, so a parent wanting to understand the economic and special-needs profile of the student body would need to ask the school directly.
On state assessments, the most recent results show a mixed but in some places encouraging picture. Math proficiency is the brighter spot: fourth grade stands out as a relative strength, with a solid majority of students scoring proficient or above, and third grade is close behind at roughly half. Fifth grade math drops off considerably, with only about three in ten reaching proficiency. In English language arts, fourth grade again leads, with a clear majority proficient. Third grade ELA is the weakest result, with under a third of students proficient, while fifth grade lands in the middle. Science was tested only in fifth grade, where about a third of students reached proficiency. Participation was full across every tested grade and subject, which means the results reflect the entire eligible cohort rather than a subset.
A parent may want to look into the fifth-grade math dip and the third-grade ELA shortfall with the school, since both represent areas where a substantial majority of students are not yet at proficiency. At the same time, the fourth-grade results in both subjects suggest that strong teaching is happening in that grade, and the school is clearly capable of moving a majority of its students to proficiency when conditions align. We looked for multi-year trend data to see whether these results represent an improvement or decline, but only a single year was available, so no direction can be read from the data.
No information was available on programs, course access, staffing ratios, attendance, discipline, or Title I status. The district brief turned up little of lasting parent-relevant change, describing a small rural system operating across a handful of schools. A family evaluating Sistersville Elementary would be looking at a school in an affordable, historically rich river town with a tight-knit, demographically narrow student body and assessment results that swing considerably from grade to grade. The strongest academic signal comes from fourth grade; the weakest appears in the upper elementary transition years. Asking the school how it supports students moving from fourth into fifth, and what interventions follow the lower third-grade ELA result, would be a productive next step.
See more original research from School Decision →