The reported proficiency rate for English language arts is 25%.
Original Research by School Decision on Saginaw Academy of Excellence
Saginaw Academy of Excellence was a single-school charter district in Michigan that operated as a STEM-focused K-through-eight institution. Publicly reported sources describe a curriculum built around science, technology, engineering, and math, with offerings in robotics, coding, and a program called The Flying Classroom. The school marked its shift to this STEM focus in the fall of its last operating year, with local officials and community leaders welcoming students back. The district's sole school is now listed as closed, so families considering this entity should understand that it is no longer operating as an active school.
The state assessment picture from the most recent reported year covers math, English language arts, science, and social studies across several elementary and middle grades. The tested groups were very small in each grade, which is typical of a single charter school with modest per-grade enrollment. In math, proficiency fell into the lowest reported range across the elementary and middle grades, with no students reaching the proficient threshold in several grades. The eighth-grade math results, assessed through the PSAT, landed in the lowest band the state reports for that measure.
English language arts showed a somewhat different pattern. In the upper elementary grades, proficiency landed in the lower reporting range. By seventh and eighth grade, a quarter of tested students reached proficiency in ELA. Science and social studies results across the tested grades also fell into the lowest reporting bands, with no students meeting the proficient standard in the grades where that count was reported. Sixth-grade results were suppressed, which often reflects very small or absent testing populations for that grade and should not be read as a weakness. Participation rate data was not available for any grade or subject.
Beyond these assessment results, the available data is quite limited. Enrollment figures, student demographics, free-or-reduced-price-lunch rates, special-population counts, and staffing information were all missing from the sources we reviewed. No graduation rate applies here because the school did not serve high school grades. There is no locale brief, housing market data, or community economic context tied to this entity, so we cannot describe the surrounding area, housing costs, or neighborhood character. Civil-rights data, course-access details, and discipline information were not provided. No comparison fact-set was available to position this district against its neighbors in the county.
The district brief does confirm one clear and lasting detail about the school's educational approach: it had committed to a STEM-oriented curriculum across all grade levels. For a family looking at this school in retrospect or comparing it to successor options, that STEM focus was the defining feature of its final iteration. The academic results, drawn from very small groups, indicate that students struggled to reach state proficiency standards across most subjects and grades, with ELA in the upper middle grades being the relative bright spot. A parent trying to understand what happened here would want to ask the authorizing body or successor school about both the academic trajectory and the circumstances of closure, since neither the data nor the publicly reported sources we reviewed explain why the school closed.
See more original research from School Decision →