The reported proficiency rate for English language arts is 25%.
Original Research by School Decision on Saginaw Academy of Excellence
Saginaw Academy of Excellence was a charter school on Malzahn Street in Saginaw, Michigan, operating as a K through eighth-grade STEM-focused institution before its closure. The school's data carries a closed operational status, so this account describes what the school was in its final reported period rather than what a parent can enroll in today.
The school publicly reported a shift to a STEM emphasis in 2022, building its curriculum around science, technology, engineering, and math. Robotics, coding, and a program called The Flying Classroom were part of that approach. Local officials and community leaders marked the transition publicly at the start of that school year. For a charter school of this size and grade band, committing to a STEM identity was a clear curricular choice, one that would appeal to families looking for an applied, technology-oriented pathway in the elementary and middle grades.
State assessment results from the final reported year paint a difficult academic picture. In math, across every tested grade with reportable results, proficiency was in the lowest reported band, and the count of students scoring proficient was zero in most grades. The state suppressed sixth-grade math results because no students were tested at that grade level. Eighth-grade math, assessed through the PSAT, also fell in the lowest band. English language arts showed somewhat more life. Seventh and eighth grades each reached a quarter of tested students scoring proficient, while the elementary grades remained in the lowest reported band with no students clearing the proficiency threshold. Science and social studies results followed the same pattern, with fifth grade in the lowest band and eighth grade in a similarly low band, and no students scoring proficient in either subject at either grade. The tested counts were small in every grade, which means a single student's results move the numbers considerably. Still, the overall pattern is one of broad academic struggle across subjects and grade levels. A parent reviewing this record would want to understand from the school directly what instructional supports and interventions were in place, especially given the STEM focus the school had adopted.
Enrollment and demographic data were not available in the provided records. We looked for total enrollment, racial and ethnic composition, free or reduced-price lunch rates, English learner counts, and special education rates, and none were reported. The grade band listed in the directory is garbled, but the district brief and public reporting confirm the school served kindergarten through eighth grade. Because the school is now closed, the absence of current enrollment data is consistent with its operational status. There is no graduation rate to report because the school did not serve high school grades. No data on discipline, course access, staffing, attendance, or Title I status was available.
Saginaw itself is a Rust Belt city with a deep manufacturing heritage. General Motors dominated employment through much of the twentieth century, and the city still carries a higher share of manufacturing jobs than the national average, though deindustrialization has driven steady population loss over decades. The city sits along the Saginaw River, about fifteen miles inland from Saginaw Bay on Lake Huron, within one of the largest freshwater coastal wetland systems in the country. Downtown Saginaw holds civic and cultural anchors including the Castle Museum, the Temple Theatre, and the Dow Event Center. Modern economic development efforts center on clean energy, innovation, and continued manufacturing exports. Public reporting did not surface details on walkability, public transit, parks, or specific new housing construction.
The housing market around the school's zip code is among the most affordable in the state. Typical home values sit far below both the Michigan and national benchmarks, and rents are similarly low relative to state levels. Both home values and rents have been edging upward recently, but from a very modest base. For families who lived in the area, housing costs would not have been a barrier to accessing the school; the academic question was the central one.
Saginaw Academy of Excellence closed after a brief period as a STEM-focused charter school in a city working through decades of economic transition. Its final assessment results show a school that struggled to move students to proficiency in any subject, with small tested populations and no reported demographic context to help interpret those numbers further. What remains is a record of ambition in its curricular direction and academic outcomes that did not yet match that ambition.
See more original research from School Decision →