School DecisionThe Newsroom
SATURDAY, SEPTEMBER 5, 2026
Beyond the headline
SCHOOLDECISION.COM/NEWSROOM
Delaware · The Data

Delaware 2026 Assessment Results Show Modest Gains; SAT Math Stagnates at 18% for Third Year

Grades 3-8 proficiency inches up 1 point each in ELA and math, but SAT math remains flat and achievement gaps persist far below pre-pandemic levels and state targets.

ELA proficiency by race/ethnicity, grades 3-8, 2026Asian74%White55%Hispanic31%Black29%
Original Research by SchoolDecision.com
Proficiency rates for the four largest racial/ethnic groups on the state ELA assessment for grades 3-8. Data from the Delaware Department of Education. [2]

On August 18, 2026, the Delaware Department of Education released the first phase of its 2026 statewide assessment results, showing that grades 3-8 English language arts proficiency rose one percentage point to 42 percent and math proficiency rose one point to 35 percent. The state's education secretary highlighted the small gains but also noted that SAT math proficiency for 11th-graders remained at 18 percent for the third consecutive year, one of the clearest areas of concern.

18%SAT math proficiency for grade 11 in Delaware, unchanged for the third consecutive year (2024-2026). [1]

Statewide trends and targets

Before the pandemic, overall proficiency for grades 3-8 stood at 53 percent in ELA and 44 percent in math. Current ELA proficiency is about 11 points behind that level, and math is about 9 points behind. The state's 2028 strategic plan targets are 53 percent for Grade 3 ELA and 35 percent for Grade 8 math. Grade 3 ELA reached 40 percent in 2026, and Grade 8 math reached 29 percent.

11 pointsShortfall from pre-pandemic ELA proficiency in 2019 for grades 3-8. Math is 9 points behind. [2]

Literacy coaching shows promise, but evidence is mixed

Among nine schools with state-supported literacy coaches and comparable Grade 3 ELA results, eight showed proficiency increases averaging 5.4 percentage points, compared with a 1-point statewide increase. The largest gains were 12 points at two schools. The Delaware Department of Education's own data is descriptive and does not include a controlled design, so it cannot establish that coaching caused the gains. No independent peer-reviewed evaluation of the program was identified in the available results.

Achievement gaps remain wide

Achievement gaps across demographic groups remain significant. Among grades 3-8, Asian students scored 74 percent ELA proficiency, white students 55 percent, Hispanic students approximately 31 percent, and Black students approximately 29 percent. English-language learners scored 15 percent, students from lower-income households 25 percent, and students with disabilities approximately 11 percent.

Comparative context: NAEP and regional peers

On the 2024 National Assessment of Educational Progress, Delaware's average Grade 4 mathematics scale score of 234 was significantly lower than the national public average of 237. Nine jurisdictions scored significantly higher than Delaware, 14 scored lower, and 30 were not significantly different. On Grade 8 mathematics, 22 jurisdictions scored higher and 20 lower. In nearby states, 44 percent of New Jersey public school students and 41 percent of Pennsylvania students performed at or above NAEP Proficient in Grade 4 mathematics, compared with 36 percent nationally. NAEP proficiency standards are set independently of state assessments and are not directly comparable to Delaware's DeSSA proficiency rates.

234Delaware's average Grade 4 mathematics scale score on the 2024 NAEP, compared with the national public average of 237. [5]

District and school variation

Among traditional districts, Cape Henlopen posted the highest grades 3-8 scores at 60 percent ELA and 53 percent math. Appoquinimink and Caesar Rodney also performed above the state average. The lowest-performing traditional district was Capital, with 26 percent ELA and 19 percent math. Among charter schools, Newark Charter School scored 74 percent ELA and 71 percent math. Lake Forest High School, highlighted by the department as a sustained-improvement example, raised SAT math proficiency from 13 percent in 2024 to 19 percent in 2026, and SAT evidence-based reading and writing from 32 percent to 44 percent.

19%SAT math proficiency at Lake Forest High School in 2026, up from 13% in 2024. [1]

Secretary of Education Cindy Marten said the department is working with districts and stakeholders to create a clearer support system for monitoring and accountability, with tiers of support and consequences for continued underperformance. The General Assembly has funded a review of Delaware's high school assessment approach to align with academic standards and postsecondary expectations.

Analysis

By the School Decision Newsroom, written after the reporting above was filed.

Marten ran San Diego's schools for eight years and the same gaps stayed wide there too.

Before arriving in Delaware in January 2025, Cindy Marten spent eight years as superintendent of San Diego Unified, California's second-largest district. Overall test scores rose during her tenure, but achievement gaps between Black and Latino students and white students remained "largely stagnant," shrinking less than 1 percentage point over three years of testing, according to Voice of San Diego. The LA Times reported those gaps exceeded 30 percentage points in both ELA and math. NAEP data show Black fourth-graders scored 40 points lower than white students in 2019 math, wider than the 27-point gap in 2003. Delaware's current gap between white and Black students in ELA is 26 points. The same leader who could not close that gap in a district of 100,000 students is now responsible for closing it statewide.

At one point per year, Delaware's 2028 proficiency targets are out of reach.

The state's own strategic plan, adopted in 2025, set a target of 53 percent for Grade 3 reading by June 2028, starting from a baseline of 38 percent. Grade 3 ELA reached 40 percent in 2026, a gain of 2 points. To hit the target, Delaware needs 13 points in two years. Grade 8 math needs 6 points (from 29 percent to 35 percent). The state has gained 1 point per year in both subjects for three consecutive years. At that pace, Grade 3 reading reaches 42 percent by 2028, eleven points short. The department's public dashboard, promised for fall 2026, will be the first place parents can see whether the state acknowledges the gap between its targets and its trajectory.

Ohio ran the same literacy coaching idea at 14 times the scale and still could only show associations.

Ohio launched its ReadOhio coaching model in 2023 with 33 coaches in 53 schools, expanding to 84 coaches in 124 schools by 2024. Its Year 2 evaluation used a controlled design with mediation analysis and found positive associations between small-group coaching and student literacy gains, with evidence that coaching improved teacher practices which in turn improved student outcomes. But even at that scale, Ohio's researchers characterized the findings as associative, not causal. Delaware's literacy coaching data covers nine schools with no control group and no peer-reviewed evaluation. The eight schools that showed gains may reflect coaching, selection effects, or something else entirely. Ohio's experience suggests the approach has promise, but Delaware's evidence base cannot yet confirm it.

Sources

  1. Delaware Department of Education (news.delaware.gov). Delaware schools receiving targeted literacy support show some of the state's strongest assessment gains View
  2. Delaware Online. Delaware's 2026 test scores show moderate growth View
  3. Spotlight Delaware. 'Replicate it': Education secretary highlights bright spots amid disappointing test scores View
  4. Spotlight Delaware (State Board briefing document). 2026 State Assessment Results Grades 3-8 — State Board Briefing View
  5. Delaware Department of Education. NAEP 2024 Results View
  6. National Center for Education Statistics (NAEP). The Nation's Report Card: 2024 Mathematics Snapshot Reports for New Jersey and Pennsylvania (Grades 4 and 8) View
  7. Voice of San Diego. Five Years in, Cindy Marten Has Notched Some Successes at San Diego Unified — But Black and Brown Students Still Struggle View
  8. Los Angeles Times. Critics decry San Diego superintendent's mixed record on equity View
  9. Delaware Department of Education. DOE Strategic Plan 2025-2028 View
  10. Delaware Department of Education. 2025 Statewide Assessment Results View
  11. Ohio Department of Education. Early Impacts of Ohio's Literacy Coaching Model: The Year 2 ReadOhio Coaching Report View
Delaware 2026 Assessment Results Show Modest Gains; SAT Math Stagnates at 18% for Third Year | School Decision