The top reported proficiency rate is 56% in English language arts. The lowest is 45% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Hill and Plain School
Hill and Plain School serves pre-kindergarten through second grade in New Milford, a town that spans a large land area with a compact, walkable downtown historic district surrounded by residential neighborhoods, rural areas, and lakefront. The school sits on Old Town Park Road, separate from the civic downtown but within a short distance of the town center.
The school enrolls students across the early elementary grades, with a student body that is majority white, with a substantial share of Hispanic students, a smaller Asian population, and limited representation of Black students. About one-third of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which reflects economic diversity in the enrollment. The school is a regular public school with no charter or magnet designation, offering a traditional elementary pathway.
State assessment data comes from a single year in the mid-2010s, when third graders (the only grade level tested at that time) showed proficiency rates below the midpoint among Western Connecticut Planning Region districts. In English Language Arts, proficiency stood at just above half; in mathematics, it was somewhat lower. The data is now over a decade old, so it provides limited current insight into how the school is performing. More recent state testing results were not available.
The school operates within the New Milford School District, which experienced significant budget turmoil in spring 2025. The Board of Finance proposed a substantial cut to education spending, triggering non-renewal notices for a large number of non-tenured teachers and raising the prospect of larger class sizes, reduced special education services, and cuts to electives and arts programs. Community backlash was strong; voters rejected the austere budget in a referendum. After a second referendum in June 2025, a restored budget passed, avoiding the teacher layoffs and restoring program funding. The resolution came with a notable increase in property tax rates for homeowners. For families considering the district, this recent budget volatility is worth understanding—it suggests both fiscal strain and active community engagement around schools, though uncertainty around year-to-year resources is a real factor.
New Milford's broader context includes slow population growth, with housing values above state and national averages and a community anchored by a large town green, vibrant downtown with retail and restaurants, and major employers in manufacturing, healthcare, and retail. The town has retained a rural character despite growth. Development activity in recent years has focused on downtown mixed-use projects and workforce housing, with some resident debate about density. Public transit is available through the regional HART system.
The specific academic profile and student support services at Hill and Plain are not detailed in available data. Parents may want to contact the school directly to learn about curriculum approach, class composition by grade, enrichment offerings, special education and English learner support, and current proficiency trends, since public data on these dimensions is limited or outdated.
See more original research from School Decision →