The top reported proficiency rate is 52% in English language arts. The lowest is 35% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Hawthorne Middle School
Hawthorne Middle School sits on Pocatello's west side, serving grades six through eight as part of Pocatello-Chubbuck School District 25. It is a regular public school, neither a charter nor a magnet, and draws from a community where nearly half the student body qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch. The enrollment is moderate for a middle school in this region, with the largest cohort in seventh grade.
The student population is predominantly white, with a meaningful American Indian and Alaska Native presence that stands out relative to many Idaho schools, along with a Hispanic population of comparable size and a smaller multiracial group. Data on students receiving special education services and English learners was not available, so those portions of the school's profile remain undescribed here.
On Idaho's ISAT, Hawthorne's English language arts results are the school's relative bright spot. Sixth-grade proficiency starts below half the class but rises meaningfully by seventh grade, and eighth grade shows a majority of students meeting the state's proficient-or-above bar. The upward trajectory across the middle grades suggests that the school's literacy work gains traction as students move through the building. Math tells a different story. Across all three grades, roughly a third to just under two-fifths of students reach proficiency, with little movement between grades. Science, tested only in eighth grade, lands in a similar range to math. These are soft areas, and a parent may want to look into how the school is addressing math and science instruction with the administration, particularly given the flat pattern from sixth through eighth grade. No multi-year trend data was available in a usable form, so it is unclear whether these results represent a recent dip, a long-standing pattern, or something in between.
Pocatello itself is the county seat of Bannock County and the principal city of the Pocatello metropolitan area in southeastern Idaho. The publicly reported economic profile describes a mix anchored by Idaho State University, manufacturing operations including Amy's Kitchen and ON Semiconductor, the Portneuf Medical Center, and financial services through Idaho Central Credit Union. The city grew historically as a railroad junction and trade center, earned the nickname "Gate City," and expanded industrially during the 1940s. The Portneuf River runs along the city's western side, and a greenway trail system of more than fifteen built miles, with more planned, follows the river through town. Cultural institutions include the Idaho Museum of Natural History, the Museum of Clean, and the Bannock County Historical Complex. The FBI is building a data center in the city, which may shape future employment and growth.
Housing in the school's zip code sits below both the state and national benchmarks for typical home values, making this one of the more affordable metropolitan-adjacent markets in Idaho. Renting is meaningfully cheaper than carrying a mortgage at current interest rates. For families weighing where to live within District 25, that cost gap between renting and owning is wide enough to shape decisions.
At the district level, Pocatello-Chubbuck School District 25 has recently redrawn elementary attendance areas to balance enrollment and capacity across schools. While that redistricting affects elementary boundaries rather than middle school assignments, it signals that the district is actively managing population shifts. The district has also adopted Visible Learning and Restorative Practices as district-wide commitments, the former focusing on how students learn rather than only what they learn, and the latter aimed at nurturing healthy relationships and building strong school communities. How those frameworks translate into day-to-day practice at Hawthorne specifically was not available in the provided material.
No neighbor comparison data was provided for this school, so its standing relative to other middle schools in the county could not be assessed. Data on discipline, course access, staffing ratios, attendance, and Title I status was also absent, leaving a partial picture of the school environment.
What the available evidence shows is a mid-sized middle school in an affordable university town, with literacy outcomes that strengthen through the upper grades and math and science results that have stayed flat and modest. Families whose children are strong readers may find good momentum here. Families concerned about math and science growth would benefit from asking the school directly about its plans for those subjects.
See more original research from School Decision →