The top reported proficiency rate is 42% in Math. The lowest is 28% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Columbus West Elementary School
Columbus West Elementary School serves pre-K through fourth grade in a densely built, working-class neighborhood of Cicero, an inner-ring suburb west of Chicago. The school's student body is overwhelmingly Hispanic, reflecting the town's demographics. Cicero itself is a fully developed, walkable community with mixed-use buildings along commercial corridors like Cermak Road, served by the CTA Pink Line and local bus routes. The median home value in the area is modest, and households tend toward lower incomes; the school's location sits in a neighborhood where most families have limited resources.
The most recent state assessment data available covers only third grade. In math, proficiency stood below halfway among the students tested. In English language arts, proficiency was considerably lower. State testing data for grades four and above was not available, which reflects the fact that while the school's official grade band extends through fourth, the fifth-grade results that would normally be reported do not appear. Fourth-grade proficiency data in particular is missing, which a parent may want to ask the school directly about. The school did report science proficiency from an earlier assessment cycle, which was also below halfway. These numbers suggest the school faces academic headwinds. The data provided includes state testing from 2024-25 but does not break out results by student subgroup or show trend data that would indicate whether performance has been improving or declining.
When Columbus West's overall proficiency is compared to other elementary schools across Cook County, it falls below the midpoint. This positioning reflects real academic gaps that would be worth exploring in conversation with the school: what is the school doing to address reading and math proficiency, what interventions are in place for struggling students, and what does the school's own assessment data show about progress mid-year and across grades.
The school enrolls a small population of fewer than a hundred fourth graders, with larger cohorts in the earlier grades, suggesting either a declining enrollment pattern or a structural shift in the school's design. The district as a whole has made structured literacy instruction a core curriculum priority since 2021, moving to explicit, systematic phonics and decoding instruction across all elementary schools, and this shift has been credited with gains in reading proficiency districtwide. Teachers are also trained in Professional Learning Communities, a model in which instructional teams use student data to plan together. These are genuine instructional changes that should be at work in Columbus West.
Free-and-reduced-price lunch data was not available, nor were English learner enrollment rates or special education enrollment rates, so the precise economic and language profile remains partially hidden. However, the town context and the student race-ethnicity data (heavily concentrated in one group) suggest a school serving families with limited economic cushion. For a parent considering this school, the questions are whether the school's recent structured literacy adoption and PLC training have meaningfully moved the needle on proficiency, what the breakdown of third-grade results looks like by subgroup, what supports are available for children who enter behind, and how the school's own assessments and growth measures tell the story that the state test alone cannot. The school is located in a neighborhood with walkable access to library, parks, and transit, and is embedded in a town with real civic anchors, which offers a particular kind of community environment.
See more original research from School Decision →