The top reported proficiency rate is 66% in English language arts. The lowest is 43% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on West Elem School
West Elem School is a kindergarten-through-fifth-grade elementary school serving about five hundred students in Crystal Lake, Illinois, a residential and mixed-use suburb northwest of Chicago in McHenry County. The school sits in a community experiencing active residential growth, with major new housing and mixed-use developments underway and two Metra commuter rail stations anchoring daily civic life. The neighborhood and school enrollment are diverse, with substantial Hispanic and white student populations and smaller shares of Asian, Black, and multiracial students.
The school's math results show a pattern of declining proficiency as grade level advances. Third-grade proficiency in math is moderate; fourth and fifth grades see significant drops, with less than two in five fifth-graders meeting proficiency standards. English language arts tells a different story. Third and fifth grades show performance in the low-to-mid range, but fourth grade stands out with notably stronger results, suggesting uneven performance across the grade band or differences in how students progress through the curriculum. Science proficiency in fifth grade is also below the midpoint. Across tested subjects, West Elem sits in the top quartile among McHenry County districts overall, but readers should understand that this comparison reflects only the district aggregate and that the school's trajectory within grades—particularly the math declines in grades four and five—merits direct conversation with school leadership about instructional focus and student support.
State testing data for grades six through eight are absent from the school's record because West Elem serves only through fifth grade; students move to middle school for those grades. Kindergarten through second grade are not tested at the state level in Illinois, so no proficiency data exist for those early years, which is standard practice statewide.
The district serving this school, Crystal Lake CCSD 47, has announced several staff and budget adjustments in early 2025 that affect the building environment. Elementary band and Extended Curriculum (gifted and enrichment) programs are being reduced in staffing, meaning fewer class periods and smaller cohorts for these offerings. Additionally, the district has worked to reposition middle school attendance boundaries, a change that took effect for the current school year and has shuffled which neighborhoods feed into which schools. A significant federal grant supporting mental health services was terminated, reducing the district's capacity for student mental health staffing and programming. Parents evaluating West Elem should understand that these changes are shaping resource availability and breadth of offerings in the near term.
The school's housing context is active and upwardly mobile. Home values in the zip code are rising modestly, and the rental market is also growing. Listings inventory in McHenry County is tightening slightly compared to a year earlier, and there is steady new housing development, including a large mixed-use project adjacent to a major recreation area. The community offers a walkable downtown Main Street, access to commuter rail, and substantial parks and lakes, mixing suburban convenience with small-town character.
West Elem serves a moderately sized student body with roughly even grade-to-grade enrollment in kindergarten through fifth. Participation in state testing is high and consistent across grades, reflecting strong school engagement in assessment and reporting. Data on free-or-reduced-price lunch eligibility and special education or English learner populations were not available, so potential insight into the school's economic and special-population composition remains incomplete.
See more original research from School Decision →