The top reported proficiency rate is 71% in Science. The lowest is 52% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Howe-manning
Howe-Manning serves grades three through six in Middleton, a fast-growing suburban town on Boston’s North Shore. The school is the only upper-elementary building in the Middleton Public Schools, drawing from the town’s primary-grade Fuller Meadow School and feeding into Masconomet Regional Middle and High Schools alongside students from Topsfield and Boxford. The enrollment is on the smaller side for a grade band this size, and the student body is predominantly white, with small shares of Asian, Hispanic, Black, and multiracial students. A parent may note that the available data did not include the share of students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch or the share receiving special education or English learner services, so the economic and support-need picture is not complete from the figures alone.
On the 2025 NextGen MCAS, about half of Howe-Manning students scored proficient or above in math, and about half did in English language arts. Science, which is tested in grade five only, showed a higher proficiency rate, with most students meeting the bar. Placing these results against the field, the school’s combined proficiency across subjects lands in the top quarter when compared with other districts in Essex County. The numbers are straightforward: the school is performing above the median for the county, but the results are not as high as the strongest-scoring suburban schools in the region.
The trend lines matter here. In the years before the pandemic, math and ELA proficiency each ran around seven in ten. After 2021, both subjects settled in the low- to mid-fifties and have stayed there through 2025. That is a clear downward shift from pre-2019 levels, and the most recent year’s numbers are the lowest in the available series. A parent moving into the district will want to ask the school how it is working to reverse that slide, and what support is in place for students who are not meeting proficiency.
Howe-Manning is a regular public school with no charter or magnet status. The town of Middleton itself is primarily residential, car-dependent, and growing fast; it is described as one of the fastest-growing communities on the North Shore. Home values are high and have risen further recently, reflecting the broader housing market in Essex County. The town has no rail service, though a rail-trail project is underway to improve connectivity. The district level brief notes that Middleton Public Schools adopted a new literacy curriculum aligned with the science of reading starting in 2023-2024, which represents a lasting shift in how early reading is taught. The district also launched a five-year strategic plan focused on academic excellence, social-emotional learning, and community engagement, and the regional high school that Howe-Manning feeds into completed a science lab renovation in 2023.
No staffing ratios, discipline data, or course access information was available in the data provided, so the reader cannot assess class sizes or program breadth from this account. The graduation rate is not applicable here since the school serves only upper elementary grades.
For a family considering Middleton, Howe-Manning presents a mixed academic picture: a county-leading position that has dropped from higher pre-pandemic levels and now holds roughly steady at a moderate proficiency rate. The school sits in a town experiencing rapid residential growth and high home prices, and it is part of a regional high school arrangement that families should understand before enrolling. A parent will want to investigate how the new literacy curriculum is affecting student outcomes, what interventions are available for students scoring below proficient, and what the transition to Masconomet Regional looks like for elementary students from Middleton.
See more original research from School Decision →