The top reported proficiency rate is 53% in English language arts. The lowest is 32% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Deal Island School
Deal Island School is a small public elementary school serving prekindergarten through fifth grade in the rural community of Deal Island, on Maryland's Eastern Shore. Because it covers only early and elementary grades, the school does not produce a graduation rate or offer high-school-level programs such as Advanced Placement, dual credit, or career pathways. The enrollment is modest, and the school is the only one in the immediate area, drawing children from the scattered homes and lanes of the peninsula.
State testing results from the 2024-25 school year provide a first look at academic performance, though only a single year of data is available, so no trend can be drawn. In mathematics, the proficiency rate for third grade and for fourth grade each fell below a third of students, meaning that in both grades roughly one in three met the state's proficiency standard. Fifth-grade math results were suppressed, which is typical when the number of test-takers is very small. In English language arts, fourth graders posted a result in which slightly more than half of students scored proficient. For third grade, the state reported the proficiency rate within a range that centered near that same level, while fifth-grade ELA data was also suppressed. Science testing in fifth grade, administered through the Maryland Integrated Science Assessment, was likewise withheld due to small numbers. Taken together, the available results show that reading proficiency sits around the halfway mark for the tested grades, while math proficiency is lower. The school is part of Somerset County Public Schools, a district that has been under corrective action by the Maryland State Department of Education because of persistently low performance—a structural factor that shapes curriculum, staffing, and resource decisions across all schools in the district.
The community surrounding Deal Island School is a small, low-density peninsula with a deep watermen heritage centered on oystering and crabbing. The built environment is scattered homes along the main road and side lanes, with few commercial structures; there is no traditional downtown. The population is small and aging, and the local economy offers limited employment opportunities, with median household income well below national averages. Housing values in the area are substantially lower than both state and national benchmarks, in line with the rural and economically modest character of the region. The community also faces significant environmental vulnerabilities: the average elevation is only about three feet, making it susceptible to flooding, erosion, and sea-level rise, and a collaborative research effort is working with residents on adaptation strategies. No major new development is occurring; the trajectory is one of stability or modest decline rather than growth.
The student body at Deal Island School reflects its setting. The vast majority of students are white, with smaller shares identifying as multiracial, Black, or Hispanic. A substantial share of families qualify for free or reduced-price meals, indicating a high level of economic need. Data on students with disabilities and English learners was not available, so a parent may want to ask the school directly about those supports. Staffing, discipline, and attendance information were also absent from the available records.
For a family considering Deal Island School, the picture is one of a very small, rural elementary school nested in a close-knit, historically grounded community. The academic results from the first year of testing suggest that reading attainment is roughly at the midpoint for the grades that could be reported, while math is lower. The district’s status under state oversight is an ongoing factor that will influence instruction and resources. The school does not serve beyond fifth grade, so families will need to plan for middle and high school elsewhere. The community itself offers a quiet, low-cost living environment with strong local identity, but limited economic opportunity and exposure to environmental risk.
See more original research from School Decision →