The top reported proficiency rate is 15% in English language arts. The lowest is 12% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Barber Elementary School
Barber Elementary School sits on Buena Vista Street in Highland Park, a small enclave city entirely surrounded by Detroit except for a sliver bordering Hamtramck. It is a charter school operating under the Highland Park Public School Academy System, serving students from pre-kindergarten through eighth grade, though its pre-kindergarten enrollment is currently zero and the school functions as a K-through-eight campus. The enrollment is small for a school spanning that many grades. The student body is almost entirely African American, and nearly all students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting the deep economic pressures in the surrounding community.
Highland Park itself carries a heavy post-industrial story. Once home to Ford's Model T plant and Chrysler's corporate headquarters, the city lost both employers over the latter decades of the twentieth century, and its population has fallen steadily from its mid-century peak. The city was under state-appointed emergency financial management for a span of years, during which civic buildings including the public library were shuttered. Publicly reported sources note that the city has seen some reinvestment in recent years, including commercial redevelopment along Woodward Avenue and a Magna International seat-production plant opening in the former Chrysler headquarters. Still, housing values here are a fraction of the statewide benchmark, and rents are well below what most Michigan communities command. For families looking at homeownership, this is one of the most affordable ZIP codes in the region.
Academically, the state assessment results for Barber are a serious concern. Across every tested grade in math, proficiency is extremely low, with most grades showing essentially no students reaching the proficient threshold on the M-STEP. English language arts results are similarly low in the elementary grades, though the upper grades show a modest uptick, with seventh and eighth grade posting the school's strongest results. Science and social studies proficiency is near zero across the grades tested. When measured against other districts in Wayne County, the school's overall proficiency sits in the bottom quartile. There is no multi-year trend data available to show whether these numbers are improving or declining over time, and the data flags a cut-score change in social studies that limits comparability. A parent considering this school may want to ask directly what academic interventions and support structures are in place, and how leadership plans to move these results.
Some expected data points are absent. Information on individualized education programs and English learner populations was not reported. No discipline, course access, staffing, or attendance data was available. The school has no graduation rate, which is expected because it does not serve high school grades. No program offerings such as advanced coursework, dual enrollment, or extracurriculars were listed. Civil-rights data was also not provided.
The locale brief notes that Highland Park reorganized its school system as a charter academy structure, and that high school students from the city are zoned to Northwestern High School in the Detroit Public Schools Community District. The district brief search found little of lasting impact from recent years beyond the earlier charter conversion and a cooperative agreement for high school placement.
For a parent weighing Barber Elementary, the picture is straightforward. It is a small, community-rooted charter school in a city working through decades of economic dislocation, with very low housing costs and convenient expressway access. The academic results, though, are weak across subjects and grades, and the available data does not include program offerings, staffing details, or student-support metrics that might offset that picture. Families would benefit from visiting the school, asking about instructional strategy and intervention plans, and understanding what the path looks like as students transition to high school in Detroit.
See more original research from School Decision →