The top reported proficiency rate is 28% in English language arts. The lowest is 10% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Randels Elementary School
Randels Elementary School sits on Brobeck Street in Flint, serving pre-kindergarten through fifth grade as part of Carman-Ainsworth Community Schools. It is a regular public school, neither a charter nor a magnet, and its enrollment is moderate for an elementary building in this area. The student body is predominantly Black, with a White minority and a smaller group of students identifying as two or more races. Hispanic students and a very small number of American Indian or Alaska Native and Asian students round out the population. Nearly every student at Randels qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch, which points to a community facing concentrated economic need. Data on English learners and students with individualized education programs was not available, so those populations cannot be characterized here.
On Michigan's M-STEP assessment for the most recent school year, Randels posted mixed results that lean low overall. English language arts is the relative bright spot: fourth graders reached proficiency at a noticeably higher rate than third or fifth graders, and that fourth-grade ELA result stands out as the school's strongest single showing. Math results were more subdued across all three tested grades, with fifth grade the weakest. Fifth-grade science and social studies proficiency were also low. Taken together, the school's overall proficiency index lands below the midpoint among districts in Genesee County, a set of roughly three dozen districts where Randels sits in the lower tier but not at the bottom. A parent comparing options in the county would want to ask school leadership how they are approaching math instruction and what supports are in place for the upper elementary grades, where results dip.
Flint itself shapes much of what surrounds Randels. The city carries the legacy of its General Motors era, when it was a manufacturing powerhouse, and it has spent decades working through the consequences of massive GM workforce reductions and population loss. Publicly reported sources describe a city that has demolished vacant structures, replaced lead service lines following the water crisis, and continues revitalization efforts centered on its downtown along Saginaw Street. Cultural events like Back to the Bricks and the Flint Jazz Festival bring periodic life to the core, and the University of Michigan-Flint campus sits near downtown. Outside that core, Flint is largely auto-dependent, with residential neighborhoods spread across a wide footprint and commercial activity concentrated along major corridors.
The housing market around Randels reflects Flint's post-industrial context. Home values in the school's zip code are well below both the Michigan and national benchmarks, making ownership relatively accessible for families with moderate incomes. The estimated monthly mortgage on a typical home here is modest, and rents are likewise low. At the county level, listing inventory has been climbing, median listing prices have risen over the past year, and homes are spending fewer days on the market than they were a year prior. That signals a Genesee County market that is active and tightening somewhat, even as prices remain affordable compared with the state. For a family looking to buy near Randels, the cost barrier is lower than in most of Michigan.
What the data does not tell us is substantial. There is no information on staffing ratios, teacher qualifications, chronic absenteeism, disciplinary incidents, course offerings beyond the standard curriculum, or program specifics such as gifted services, arts, or extracurriculars. The school's Title I status was not reported, though the free-or-reduced-price lunch rate would typically make a school eligible. Carman-Ainsworth Community Schools did not return a district brief, so any recent strategic changes, facility investments, or academic initiatives at the district level could not be included. A family seriously considering Randels would want to ask the school directly about classroom staffing, attendance patterns, and what enrichment or intervention programs exist alongside the core curriculum.
What is clear from the available evidence is that Randels serves a community with deep economic challenges inside a city still finding its footing after years of disinvestment. Its academic results show a school where some grades are outperforming others in reading but where math and science remain areas of concern. The surrounding neighborhood offers affordable housing in a city with genuine civic and cultural assets, and the broader county housing market is showing signs of increased demand. For a family weighing Randels, the decision will likely come down to comfort with the proficiency levels shown in the data and what the school can demonstrate about its plans for improvement.
See more original research from School Decision →