The top reported proficiency rate is 36% in English language arts. The lowest is 31% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Kreamer Street Elementary School
Kreamer Street Elementary serves children in kindergarten through third grade in Bellport, a small residential village on Long Island's South Shore known for tree-lined streets, historic homes, and proximity to the bay. The school sits on a campus shared with other district buildings, outside the village's walkable commercial core.
The school has a population of about that size for its grade band, with roughly half the students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch. Enrollment reflects the area's diversity: children identify as Hispanic, white, Black, or multiracial, with a small number of Asian students. The district does not report counts of students with individualized education plans or English learners in its public data, so a parent may want to inquire directly about how many children in the building have those designations and what support infrastructure exists.
In the most recent state testing year, third-graders' proficiency in English language arts and math fell well below what is typical statewide. Across both subjects, roughly one in three students met the proficiency standard. When compared to the districts across Suffolk County, this school's overall proficiency index places it in the bottom quartile. This is a factual weak spot. A parent considering this school should ask the principal and teacher what reading and math support looks like in the classroom, what intervention services are available, and what progress data they track for students working below grade level. It is reasonable to ask whether the school has a reading specialist, a math coach, or structured small-group instruction, and how the school communicates with families about their child's progress.
The broader context matters. South Country Central School District, which operates this school, disclosed in October 2025 that it overspent its budget significantly, wiping out most of its general fund balance and forcing a multi-year fiscal recovery. An April 2026 review by the New York State Comptroller found the district continues on track for another substantial deficit despite spending freezes and staff layoffs already underway. The district has pursued special legislation to finance the gap through deficit bonds and state aid, but the path forward involves constrained budgets, potential program cuts, and multi-year debt repayment. Families are also facing a referendum on transportation that, if it passes, would eliminate busing beyond state-required distances. For a family choosing this school, these fiscal pressures could mean fewer enrichment offerings, larger class sizes, and continued uncertainty around which programs will survive the recovery period.
The housing market in Bellport itself is stable at high value, with homes in the historic village core ranging from mid-range to several million dollars. The adjacent hamlet of North Bellport, which also feeds into South Country schools, is more economically diverse and is undergoing revitalization with new affordable housing projects. Renting is a viable option for families; median monthly housing costs for renters are moderate relative to local household income, though rising.
The town itself is walkable and centered on bay access, with strong civic anchors including the South Country Library and village-run recreation. The LIRR Bellport station provides commuter rail, though ridership is low. Most residents drive. Employment is concentrated in education, health care, and public service; larger employers sit in nearby Patchogue and Medford.
For families looking at Kreamer Street, the immediate decision turns on academic performance and the question of support for students working below proficiency, the district's current fiscal instability and what it may mean for class composition and offerings over the next few years, and whether the school's size and setting align with their child's needs. It is a neighborhood school in a small, appealing residential community, but the test data and district budget situation warrant careful conversation with school staff before enrolling.
See more original research from School Decision →