Original Research by School Decision on Brook Avenue Elementary School
Brook Avenue Elementary School serves the early grades in Bay Shore, a mixed-use waterfront hamlet on Long Island's South Shore with a revitalized downtown core, marina access, and LIRR commuting to Manhattan. The school enrolls a little under four hundred students in kindergarten through second grade.
The school's student body is predominantly Hispanic, with a substantial share of students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting the economic diversity of the Bay Shore neighborhood. The enrollment is balanced across the three grade levels served. State assessment data for early elementary grades is not available, as New York does not conduct statewide testing in grades K-2, so the school's academic standing cannot be measured against state benchmarks or compared to other elementary schools in the county. Parents looking to understand academic performance would need to speak directly with the school about its reading and math instruction, early literacy screening, and how it identifies and supports students who need extra help in these critical foundational years.
The school is located in a neighborhood shaped by ongoing revitalization. Housing in the Bay Shore zip code has shown modest appreciation, and the market has shifted toward greater inventory, with median days on market shorter than a year ago. Rental housing in the area has grown through new mixed-use developments like Shoregate and Eleven Maple near the LIRR station, adding younger families and renters to what was historically a single-family-home neighborhood. The school's catchment feeds into a district of eight schools that has significantly expanded universal Pre-K through a state-funded initiative, housed in a dedicated facility, offering free full-day preschool for four-year-olds before they enter kindergarten.
After several years of essentially flat school-tax levies through 2024, the district's property-tax burden began rising again in the 2025-26 budget, a shift families considering the area should factor into their housing and relocation calculus. The LIRR station and ferry terminal to Fire Island are civic anchors nearby, and the elementary school sits within the walkable downtown rather than on an isolated campus.
No information on special education services, English learner support, staffing levels, or school-level discipline data was available. Parents should ask the school directly about how it serves students with learning differences and students who are learning English as an additional language, as these populations are part of many early elementary cohorts and support quality varies considerably by school.
See more original research from School Decision →