The top reported proficiency rate is 100% in Social studies. The lowest is 54% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Dutch Lane School
Dutch Lane School is a public elementary school in Hicksville, serving children from pre-kindergarten through fifth grade within the Hicksville Union Free School District. Its enrollment is small relative to what might be expected across that full grade span, and the student body is notably diverse: Asian and Hispanic students together account for roughly three-quarters of the school's population, with white students making up most of the remainder. A substantial share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, pointing to a meaningful range of household economic circumstances in the building.
On the New York State Testing Program, Dutch Lane's results are mixed across grades. Fourth-grade math stands out as a clear strength, with the clear majority of tested students reaching proficiency. Third-grade math and fifth-grade math both land at roughly three-fifths proficient. ELA results are more modest across the board, ranging from about half proficient in third and fourth grade to just over half in fifth grade. Fifth-grade science results are encouraging, with more than two-thirds of tested students reaching proficiency, though the number of students tested in that grade is quite small and the participation rate in particular warrants attention. Participation rates across several grades and subjects are below what one might expect, which can affect how representative the reported results actually are; parents may want to ask the school directly about testing participation. Trend data was not available, so it is not possible to say whether these results are improving, holding steady, or declining.
Placed against districts across Nassau County, Dutch Lane's overall proficiency sits above the midpoint among that group, which is a meaningful position in a county with a wide range of school systems, many of them highly regarded.
The district context matters here. Publicly reported coverage indicates Hicksville UFSD was identified by New York State as a Target District on the 2025-26 accountability list, with one elementary school flagged for additional targeted support and improvement. It is not confirmed from the data whether Dutch Lane is that specific school, and parents would do well to ask the district directly. The district also faced a real budget squeeze heading into 2025-26, with a deficit that threatened cuts to athletics, clubs, AP coursework, fine arts, and third-grade music before a retirement incentive and reserve transfers closed the gap. The district pierced the state tax cap and needed a supermajority of voters to approve its budget, which passed. A separate change eliminated an instructional period for sixth and seventh graders in favor of a "success studio," a shift that does not directly affect Dutch Lane's grades but signals the kind of tradeoffs the district has been making. Voters separately approved a technology capital reserve at no additional tax cost.
Data on English language learner status and students with IEPs was not available in this dataset, so the picture of student support services is incomplete. No program or course-access information was provided for Dutch Lane specifically.
Hicksville itself sits in central Nassau County roughly thirty miles east of Manhattan, with a strong commercial corridor along major roadways and an increasingly transit-oriented downtown core being reshaped around its Long Island Rail Road station. That station is one of the most heavily used on Long Island and is undergoing a substantial modernization. A state Downtown Revitalization Initiative is driving new mixed-use housing adjacent to the station, with pedestrian-oriented retail built into the ground floors of new projects. Cantiague Park provides meaningful recreational amenity with a golf course, ice rink, pools, and tennis. The housing market in the area is expensive relative to state and national benchmarks, and rents have been rising at a notably faster pace than home values year over year. For families considering a move, the cost of entry is high and the market moves quickly, with median time on market in Nassau County quite short during the spring season.
Dutch Lane fits a family looking for a diverse, relatively small elementary school in a community undergoing real change, with proficiency that sits in solid territory for Nassau County but with budget pressures and accountability designations at the district level that deserve direct follow-up.
See more original research from School Decision →