The top reported proficiency rate is 100% in Social studies. The lowest is 68% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on South Hill School
South Hill School sits on South Hill in Ithaca, a short distance from the Ithaca College campus, and serves children from pre-kindergarten through fifth grade as part of the Ithaca City School District. The school's location in one of Ithaca's quieter residential neighborhoods is a different experience from the denser, more student-oriented Collegetown corridor, though the city's core — with its pedestrian Commons, public library, transit hub, and lakefront trail network — is accessible from the hill by bus or car.
The academic picture at South Hill is genuinely strong in the early tested grades and somewhat more mixed in the upper elementary years. Third graders tested at a high rate of proficiency in both English language arts and math on the New York State Testing Program, placing South Hill's third-grade results well above most of its peers relative to districts in Tompkins County. By fourth and fifth grade, proficiency rates in both subjects come down to a more moderate range — still above the midpoint among the county's districts when all tested grades and subjects are averaged together, where South Hill sits in the top quartile — but the grade-to-grade variation is real and parents may want to ask the school directly about what explains it and how students are supported through those transitions. Fifth-grade science results land in a solid range. Social studies data from the current period was not available; the only social studies result on file is from a much earlier school year and should not be treated as current. Trend data across years was not available, so it is not possible to say whether results have been improving, holding, or declining.
Roughly a quarter of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which is on the lower end for an urban New York elementary school. The student population is predominantly white, with Hispanic students forming the next largest group and a meaningful share of students identifying as two or more races. IEP and English learner data were not reported in the data available, so those support structures are a gap worth exploring directly with the school.
The broader Ithaca City School District context matters for any family weighing a move. Voters approved a substantial capital bond project in May 2025 — covering building renovations, site improvements, and transportation infrastructure — that will be repaid through local property taxes over many years, a commitment that bears on tax bills for the foreseeable future. A year earlier, voters rejected an initial budget that proposed a tax levy increase exceeding New York's statutory cap, which signals that the district's fiscal relationship with its taxpayer base is under some strain. On the curriculum side, the district has publicly adopted new standardized curricula in core subjects including reading and writing, a shift worth understanding if literacy approach matters to your family.
Perhaps the most consequential background item for families choosing a home based on a specific elementary school: a Cornell-conducted demographic study released publicly in early 2026 found that most district elementary buildings are operating well below capacity, and the board has commissioned work to evaluate potential consolidation. No closures are planned and no timeline has been announced, but the possibility that attendance boundaries or building assignments could change over a multi-year horizon is a real consideration for prospective residents.
On housing, Ithaca's market sits below the New York State median home value but meaningfully above the national figure, with modest year-over-year appreciation. Rents have also risen modestly in the same period. The rent-to-income ratio is in a workable range by national standards, though Ithaca's college-town character keeps rental demand persistent.
Ithaca itself rewards the kind of family that values walkable civic infrastructure, access to arts and outdoor recreation, and a university-anchored economy. The South Hill neighborhood specifically offers a somewhat quieter residential setting within that broader city, with the Commons, the eight-mile Cayuga Waterfront Trail, and TCAT's bus network all reachable. South Hill School, within that context, posts results that compare favorably among county peers overall, with a pattern in the third grade that is particularly strong and a middle-elementary stretch worth asking more questions about.
See more original research from School Decision →