The top reported proficiency rate is 92% in Social studies. The lowest is 33% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Holmes Elementary School
Holmes Elementary sits on Dupont Avenue in Tonawanda, serving children from pre-kindergarten through fourth grade within the Kenmore-Tonawanda Union Free School District. Before describing academics or community, there is something a family needs to know up front: as of early 2026, the district was publicly weighing a proposal, reported by local news outlets, that would close Holmes Elementary, lease its building, reopen two previously shuttered schools elsewhere in the district, and reconfigure grade structures across several buildings. The plan was driven by budget pressure and enrollment loss to charter and private schools, and Holmes families raised active concerns about the impact on their neighborhood community. If approved, implementation would take a few years. That process is unresolved, and it is the most consequential thing a family considering Holmes should ask the district directly about.
On academics, New York State testing data from the most recent year covers third and fourth graders in math and English language arts. Third-grade math proficiency sits below half of students tested, and fourth-grade math proficiency is considerably lower, closer to one in five. ELA results follow a similar pattern, with third grade landing below half and fourth grade at roughly three in ten. Taken together, Holmes falls below the midpoint among districts in Erie County on an overall proficiency index, based on the comparison set for Erie County districts. Science data is available only from a much earlier school year, showing a majority of fourth graders at proficiency at that time, but that figure is too dated to carry weight for a current family. Social studies data is older still and not actionable. A parent reviewing these results may want to ask the school specifically about what academic support structures are in place and how the district tracks individual student growth over time, since the data here reflects a school where a substantial portion of students are not yet meeting grade-level benchmarks.
The student body is racially and ethnically mixed, with white students representing the largest single group, followed by Black students, Hispanic students, and students of two or more races, alongside smaller Asian and Pacific Islander populations. The most striking demographic characteristic is economic: a very large share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, well above what one typically sees in suburban Erie County schools. This shapes the school's resource environment and context for the test results. Data on English learners and students with IEPs was not available in the provided information.
The Kenmore-Tonawanda district made a real commitment to early childhood in recent years, publicly reported, expanding its universal pre-kindergarten program from half-day to full-day and re-opening a formerly closed building to house it through a YMCA partnership. Demand has been strong enough to require a lottery when applications exceed slots, which reflects genuine community interest. For families with very young children, that early-learning infrastructure is worth investigating. The district also completed a multi-year capital project, approved by voters before construction began in 2021, that renovated aging school buildings across the district, including secured entrances, updated utilities, and facility improvements. Holmes would have been part of that work, though the proposed closure discussion adds complexity to how those investments land long-term.
Tonawanda itself is a small Erie County city where manufacturing history meets an active waterfront. The downtown along Main Street is organized around a walkable core, and publicly reported plans include a state Downtown Revitalization Initiative award announced in late 2024, a new mixed-use waterfront development replacing a long-vacant parcel, and trail extensions connecting to the broader Empire State Trail. Beyond the downtown core, the broader area is car-oriented, with commercial activity spread along major arterials. Housing here is meaningfully more affordable than the New York State average, and the local market has seen modest home-value appreciation. Rents have ticked up at a slightly faster pace, though the area remains well below state norms. Erie County's housing market overall has been active, with days on market staying relatively short even as inventory has grown.
The single most important follow-up for any family right now is the restructuring question. Holmes as a physical school and attendance zone may look different within a few years, or may not change at all. The district is the right source for the current status of that proposal.
See more original research from School Decision →