The top reported proficiency rate is 21% in English language arts. The lowest is 5% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Harding Elementary School
Harding Elementary is a school serving prekindergarten through fifth grade in the residential core of Youngstown, a post-industrial city that has been shrinking steadily since the 1970s but is beginning a deliberate rebound downtown and around Youngstown State University. The school itself enrolls a small to mid-sized student body with a racially and ethnically diverse population, predominantly Black students, followed by a substantial share of Hispanic students and meaningful representation across other groups. Specific free-or-reduced-price lunch data and special education enrollment figures were not available, so a parent should inquire directly with the school about access to meal support and special services.
Academic performance at Harding is a substantial concern. In the most recent state testing data available, proficiency rates across subjects are notably low. In English language arts, about one in five students tested met or exceeded state proficiency standards. Math proficiency was considerably lower, with roughly one in ten students at that level. Science proficiency, where only a smaller subset of students were tested, stood at just a few proficient students out of those assessed. These results place Harding in the bottom quartile when compared to other districts in Mahoning County. The school's overall proficiency index reflects this pattern. Trend data covering multiple years was not available to show whether performance is improving, stable, or declining further, so a parent may want to ask the school directly about recent academic trajectories and any interventions underway. Student participation in testing was near universal, indicating that the low proficiency numbers reflect actual performance rather than a testing coverage issue.
The Youngstown City School District, Harding's parent district, is navigating significant transitions. The district returned to locally elected school board governance in 2022 after years under state-appointed management, though it remains under an academic improvement mandate. In early 2024, the district implemented an elementary school reconfiguration that closed Kirkmere Elementary and reassigned students to other buildings, including some to Harding's school; depending on a student's address, bus rides may now be substantially longer than before. More consequentially, a June 2025 announcement unveiled a two-phase high school consolidation beginning in the 2026-27 school year that will merge Youngstown's two traditional high schools into one and its two middle schools into one, a restructuring that families with children currently in lower grades will want to understand as those children progress through the system. Starting next school year, all high school juniors and seniors will be required to choose either a career-and-technical pathway through Choffin Career and Technical Center or enroll in College Credit Plus college courses, fundamentally reshaping what a traditional high school experience looks like in this district.
Youngstown itself is a city with aging housing stock, considerable vacant land, and pockets of ongoing revitalization, particularly downtown and around the university. Home values in the area are substantially below state and national medians, making housing affordable, and rental costs are similarly low. The city's largest employers are now the university and Mercy Health hospital; steel once dominated, but the economy has shifted significantly. Downtown has walkable streets with restaurants, theaters, and cultural institutions, and the city operates a free bus system. The broader region is investing in recovery, with ongoing downtown development, new housing construction, and regional branding around the emerging EV battery industry. Families considering Harding should expect a school serving a community in transition, with academic performance that falls well below county benchmarks and systemic district changes unfolding at the high school level in the years ahead.
See more original research from School Decision →