The top reported proficiency rate is 33% in Social studies. The lowest is 6% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Chaney Middle at Mcguffey
Chaney Middle at McGuffey serves grades six through eight in Youngstown and is a regular public school in the Youngstown City district. The school is located on South Schenley Avenue in the city.
The student body is diverse in racial composition, with roughly half Black students, a meaningful share of Hispanic students, and smaller populations of white and multiracial students. The school is small for its grade band, with enrollment spread fairly evenly across the three grades.
Academic performance is very low across the board. On Ohio's State Tests in reading and math, the school's proficiency rate sits in the single digits. Science proficiency is higher but still below what would be considered grade-level mastery for most students. The school's overall proficiency index places it in the bottom quartile among districts in Mahoning County. State testing data for science shows the strongest recent result, though still modest. Social studies data from a prior year is available but represents older assessment practices and is not directly comparable to current state testing.
For parents weighing options in Youngstown, this is critical context: Chaney Middle, like other schools in the Youngstown City district, is operating under state academic distress oversight and an academic improvement plan. The district itself has undergone significant structural changes. In January 2024, the district consolidated elementary schools and relocated students, including reassigning families based on attendance zones. More substantially, in June 2025, the district announced a two-phase reconfiguration that will merge Chaney Middle with the other traditional middle school and consolidate the high schools into a single building. Beginning the 2026-27 school year, all juniors and seniors will be required to either pursue a pathway at Choffin Career and Technical Center or enroll in College Credit Plus courses, fundamentally reshaping the high school experience.
Youngstown itself is a post-industrial Rust Belt city with a long trajectory of population decline but some recent downtown revival around Youngstown State University, new housing, and arts-and-entertainment initiatives. Housing costs in the 44509 zip code are low relative to national and state benchmarks. The region is branding itself as "Voltage Valley" around the Ultium Cells battery plant and other emerging manufacturing. The city operates a free public transit system, and civic life concentrates downtown and at the university rather than in isolated neighborhoods.
A parent considering this school should understand that academic performance here is substantially below proficiency benchmarks and that the district is actively restructuring. The consolidation to Youngstown High School starting in 2026-27 means middle-school choices have less weight for high school continuity than in districts not undergoing such changes. State testing data was not available for free-or-reduced-price lunch status, special education enrollment, or English learner numbers, so a parent may want to look into those details directly with the school to understand the support structures in place.
See more original research from School Decision →