The top reported proficiency rate is 14% in Science. The lowest is 0% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Youngstown Virtual Academy
Youngstown Virtual Academy is a small online school serving grades five through twelve within the Youngstown City district, located at a street address in the city but operating as a remote option for students across the district and potentially beyond. The school had fewer than one hundred students enrolled at the time of this profile, spread across the seven grades it serves, with secondary students making up the largest share.
The student body is racially diverse, with roughly equal representation from Black and white students, along with meaningful enrollment from students of Hispanic background and a smaller group identifying as multiracial. Data on free-or-reduced-price lunch eligibility and on special education and English learner populations were not available.
Academic performance measured by state testing is a significant concern. In mathematics and English language arts for grades three through eight, the school reported zero students reaching proficiency levels in the most recent testing year, with small numbers of students tested in each subject. In the one other assessed subject for which recent data appeared, eighth-grade science, the proficiency rate was very low. The school's overall proficiency index across tested subjects and grades places it in the bottom quartile relative to districts countywide in Mahoning County. No graduation rate data was available, as this profile does not yet reflect outcomes for seniors who have completed the school's program. State testing data for science came from the prior year, and average scale scores were not disclosed for any subject.
The very small sample sizes in testing—around a dozen or fewer students per subject—suggest the school either serves a genuinely small enrollment or that participation varies. The school's website and program structure were not reviewed. A parent considering this school should contact it directly to understand its curriculum approach, student support services, synchronous and asynchronous instruction balance, technical requirements, accreditation status, and specific college and career pathways available to secondary students. They should also ask how the school performs with students who stay enrolled for multiple years and whether families find the virtual format sustainable given their household circumstances.
Youngstown itself is a post-industrial Rust Belt city rebuilding from decades of population decline tied to the collapse of steel manufacturing. Downtown and the Youngstown State University corridor have become centers of recent reinvestment, with new apartments, restaurants, entertainment venues, and cultural institutions replacing vacant and blighted properties. The broader city still carries the infrastructure burden of its much larger past population; residential neighborhoods are spread thinly and car-dependent outside the compact downtown core, which benefits from free public transit. Mill Creek Park is a major regional recreational anchor. The cost of housing is low relative to national standards and to state averages. Employment is now anchored by the university, a hospital system, and regional battery and advanced manufacturing, in contrast to the steel industry that once dominated. Population has declined significantly over recent decades, though the rate of decline has slowed. The economic picture remains tight for many households, and a property tax levy for school operations requires homeowner contributions through 2028.
The Youngstown City School District itself has undergone substantial governance and structural changes in recent years. After operating under state-appointed leadership through an academic distress commission, the district returned to locally elected school board governance in 2022 and now operates under a state-mandated academic improvement plan. In early 2024 the district closed an elementary school and reassigned its students, and in June 2025 announced plans to consolidate both high schools and both middle schools into unified buildings beginning in the 2026-27 school year. High school students will be required to either pursue a career and technical pathway through the Choffin Career and Technical Center or enroll in college credit courses, a major restructuring of secondary choice. Virtual academies can serve families whose school of assignment does not meet their needs or who face barriers to traditional attendance, but the very weak testing results here require direct inquiry into whether the school has the capacity and expertise to serve its current students effectively.
See more original research from School Decision →