The top reported proficiency rate is 40% in Math. The lowest is 19% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Keystone Public School
Keystone Public School is a single-building district that serves students from pre-kindergarten through eighth grade, a small school of about 300 students set in a rural pocket west of Sand Springs, Oklahoma, near Keystone Lake and the Keystone Ancient Forest. The school sits on Highway 51, a two-lane road that runs through the Cross Timbers, and it is the only school in the Keystone district, meaning children in the area attend the same campus from early childhood through middle school before transitioning to a high school in Sand Springs or another nearby district. The student body is predominantly white, with a sizable share of students who identify as two or more races and a notable presence of American Indian or Alaska Native students, reflecting the region’s demographics. Enrollment runs slightly smaller in the upper grades, a pattern common in rural communities where families are few and some may send older children elsewhere.
State testing data for the 2024-25 school year provides a mixed academic picture. In math, proficiency rates varied by grade, with a majority of sixth graders meeting the state standard but fewer than two in five third graders doing so, and just over a quarter of eighth graders reaching that bar. Several grade-level results were suppressed by the state due to small group sizes, which is typical for a small school and makes it difficult to see a clear trend across all years. In English language arts, the numbers were lower. A small fraction of third graders scored proficient, and the share fell to a very low level in fifth and seventh grades, while fourth and eighth graders had slightly higher but still modest results. Science results for fifth and eighth graders were suppressed entirely, so no conclusion can be drawn there. Compared with other districts across Tulsa County, Keystone’s overall proficiency index sits above the midpoint, meaning that despite the soft spots in certain grades, the school is not among the lowest-performing in the county. A parent may want to ask the school directly about the reading and writing support available in the middle grades, where the state data shows the weakest outcomes.
No high school graduation rate exists here, as the school ends at eighth grade. Information on free or reduced-price meal eligibility, special education services, and English learner populations was not available in the source data, leaving a gap in understanding the school’s economic and support needs. The same is true for chronic absenteeism, discipline, and course access; none of those metrics were reported.
The surrounding community of Sand Springs is a western suburb of Tulsa that has grown steadily over the decades. It began as a planned model town and retains a mix of older neighborhoods, industrial heritage in glass and oil, and newer development. The most significant recent change is a Google data center approved in early 2026 to be built on annexed land north of town, bringing a large private investment and new infrastructure. Housing in the school’s ZIP code is priced around the middle of the state’s range, with rents slightly lower than a typical mortgage payment for a buyer, a pattern that could appeal to families looking for a more affordable entry point than central Tulsa. The area offers outdoor recreation at Keystone State Park and the Keystone Ancient Forest, which was the first forest in Oklahoma inducted into the Old-Growth Forest Network.
Keystone Public School is a small, rural-style elementary and middle school whose academic results vary noticeably by grade and subject, with English language arts standing out as an area where families may want to dig deeper. Its setting is quiet and close to lake and forest, and its size means that teachers and students know one another across the years. The comparison with other Tulsa County districts suggests it is not an outlier on the low end, but the school’s own internal performance shows clear room for improvement in literacy. For a family seeking a tight-knit PK-8 experience on the western edge of the Tulsa metro area, Keystone offers that, but with academic outcomes that merit attention.
See more original research from School Decision →