The top reported proficiency rate is 22% in Science. The lowest is 4% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Barry Comm John Sch
Barry Comm John School serves pre-kindergarten through eighth grade in North Philadelphia. It is a neighborhood public school with an enrollment of roughly five hundred students, the vast majority of whom qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The student body is predominantly Black, with smaller populations of Hispanic, multiracial, and Asian students and very few white students.
The school's state assessment results show persistent and serious academic challenges. In the most recent math testing data available, proficiency in grades three through eight stood at a very low rate; in English language arts, proficiency was also well below state expectations; science proficiency, measured in 2022-23, was similarly depressed. These results reflect a school where the majority of students are not meeting grade-level standards. A parent may want to look into this further with the school itself, asking what targeted supports are available for students who are not proficient, what the school's remediation and tutoring programs look like, and what gains, if any, are being tracked year to year.
The school sits in North Philadelphia, a densely urban area. Philadelphia as a city is among the most walkable in the nation and is known for its rowhouse neighborhoods, strong neighborhood identities, and extensive public transit. The city's economy is anchored by healthcare, higher education, and life sciences. The housing market in the school's ZIP code is significantly below the city's broader median and also below Pennsylvania's state median; rents are more affordable than purchase prices relative to household income.
The Philadelphia City School District has undergone substantial curriculum reform. Beginning in 2023-24, the district adopted a standardized math curriculum (Illustrative Mathematics K-12) and, a year later, a science-of-reading approach to early literacy (EL Education for K-8). These changes set a uniform instructional baseline across all district schools for the first time in years. After the first year of the new reading curriculum, district-wide reading proficiency declined slightly, and early reception from teachers has been mixed. The district also received a major boost in funding: the city increased school funding from property tax revenue and a 2024 property reassessment is set to add to the schools' revenue base over the coming years.
In April 2026 the school district's board approved a sweeping facilities master plan that will close seventeen schools beginning in 2026-27, consolidate six others, and modernize dozens of campuses over the next decade. Parents should confirm whether Barry Comm John is affected by these changes, as the plan reshapes school catchments and programs across the city.
Barry Comm John is a small elementary-to-middle school in a high-poverty, predominantly Black neighborhood, with test performance well below grade-level standards. It operates within a district that has just implemented new, standardized curricula and is about to undergo the largest facilities reorganization in years. The school serves students with urgent academic needs; a parent considering this school should have a clear, direct conversation with the school's leadership about what happens when students fall short and what the path to catching up looks like.
See more original research from School Decision →