The top reported proficiency rate is 50% in Science. The lowest is 28% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Edgar Fahs Smith Steam Academy
Edgar Fahs Smith STEAM Academy serves pre-kindergarten through grade 8 in York, a small historic Pennsylvania city undergoing downtown revitalization alongside suburban residential growth in surrounding townships. The school is a regular public school within York City School District, which in late 2022 became the first Pennsylvania district to exit state financial recovery status after roughly a decade of oversight. The district has since received substantial increases in state funding under the new adequacy formula, enabling expanded staffing and resources across its schools.
The academy enrolls a small student body across ten grades, with relatively even distribution among grade levels. The school population is majority students of color: about half Black and about half Hispanic, with a small number of students identifying as white, Asian, multiracial, or American Indian. All students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting the economic composition of the school's catchment.
On Pennsylvania's System of School Assessment, the school's performance sits below the median among York County districts. In English language arts, about one-third of tested students (grades 3-8) scored at proficient levels or above. Math proficiency was lower, at roughly one-quarter of tested students. Science proficiency, measured in the 2022-23 school year, was at one-half of students. The school's proficiency index—a composite of all tested subjects and grades—placed it in the bottom quartile relative to county districts. A parent may want to look into the school's specific interventions and support structures with the district, given these results and the broader context of the district's recent transition out of financial recovery.
The school carries the STEAM designation, pointing to an emphasis on science, technology, engineering, arts, and mathematics integration, though specific course offerings and program details were not available in the data. The academy appears to be a neighborhood school rather than a magnet or choice program; data on special education enrollment, English learner support, and other staffing details were not provided.
York itself has undergone visible revitalization in recent years. The downtown, centered on Market Street, blends restored historic buildings with restaurants, breweries, arts venues, and new residential conversions. Central Market, Martin Library, and the newly opened York County History Center (in the redeveloped Steam Plant) anchor civic life. The city is walkable, with a reported walk score in the low-to-mid range, and is served by rabbittransit's fixed-route bus network connecting to surrounding communities and regions. Major employers in York County include York Hospital, Amazon, WellSpan Health, Walmart, and Harley-Davidson, alongside smaller manufacturers and food companies. Housing values in the York zip code are moderate relative to state and national benchmarks, and rental costs remain accessible, making the area affordable for families on varied incomes.
The school's location on Texas Avenue places it in a residential neighborhood within the city proper, distinct from the suburban township developments (Hudson Ridge, Bridgewater, Gotham Place) being built on the outskirts. For families considering Edgar Fahs Smith, the school offers a neighborhood-based STEAM focus within a district now moving forward under local control and with renewed state funding. The lower state assessment results warrant direct conversation with school leadership about academic support, classroom practices, and any recent changes in staffing or programming tied to the district's new resources.
See more original research from School Decision →