The top reported proficiency rate is 69% in Social studies. The lowest is 56% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Defeated Elementary
Defeated Elementary is a regular public school serving pre-kindergarten through eighth grade in Carthage, Tennessee, part of the Smith County district. It is a small school that sits in a rural setting, drawing students from the northern part of the county near Defeated Creek. Carthage itself is a compact county-seat town on the Cumberland River, historically a steamboat port, with a courthouse-square downtown and a population that has been nearly flat for years. The school is one of several in the county, and the district recently approved a budget without a property tax increase that included pay raises for staff and a new school resource officer position; a new middle school facility has been under discussion for some time but has not yet been approved.
On state assessments, Defeated Elementary posted proficiency rates above the halfway mark across the board in the most recent testing year. Results are strongest in social studies, where a large majority of students scored at the proficient level or above. Science also came in well above the midpoint. In math, roughly three-fifths of students were proficient, and in English language arts, just over half were. Participation rates were near one hundred percent, meaning nearly every enrolled student in the tested grades took the exams. The school does not serve high school grades, so there is no graduation rate to report. Because the cohort of districts in Smith County is too small for meaningful comparisons, the standard proficiency index and other comparative metrics were not available.
The student body is predominantly white, with very small numbers of Black, Hispanic, and multiracial students enrolled. The total enrollment is moderate for a PK-through-8 school. Data on the share of students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch was not reported, nor were counts of students with disabilities or English learners. A parent interested in those support structures would need to follow up with the school directly. No discipline data, staffing ratios, or chronic absenteeism information were available in the record.
Housing in the area is modest relative to state and national benchmarks. The typical home value in the school’s ZIP code is below the Tennessee median, and monthly mortgage and rent costs are manageable. The local unemployment rate has been steady near four percent, and real median household income nationally has been trending up gradually. Carthage’s housing stock is mostly owner-occupied, and no major new developments were identified in publicly reported sources. The town’s growth has been minimal, and the industrial base shifted away from the riverfront long ago; today the largest employers include the county government, a regional medical center, and the school district.
For families, Defeated Elementary offers an academic record that is solid but not standout: core proficiency rates are consistently above half, with particular strength in social studies and science. The school is small, located in a quiet rural county seat with limited economic growth. The absence of data on economic disadvantage and special populations means a family should ask the school directly about the level of support for students who need extra help. The district’s recent budget decisions have avoided a tax increase while funding staff raises and technology, which signals fiscal stability. A new middle school remains a possibility, but no timeline or commitment is in place. This is a school that fits a family looking for a small, rural elementary-through-middle school in a stable, low-growth community where the academic baseline is decent and housing is relatively affordable.
See more original research from School Decision →