The top reported proficiency rate is 49% in Science. The lowest is 32% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Smith County Middle School
Smith County Middle School serves grades five through eight in Carthage, Tennessee, a small county-seat town on the Cumberland River that is part of the Nashville metropolitan area. The school is a regular public school and is not a charter or magnet. It sits close to the historic downtown square anchored by the Smith County Courthouse, following the traditional small-town pattern where schools and civic life are clustered together rather than separated onto distant campuses.
Enrollment at the school is mid-sized for its grade band, and the student body is predominantly white, with a notable share of Hispanic students and a smaller share of students identifying as two or more races. Data on how many students qualify for free or reduced-price meals, receive special education services, or are English learners was not available in the profile, so a family wanting to understand those aspects of student support and need would need to ask the school directly. State testing data is available for math, English language arts, science, and social studies, and the school’s participation rate across all tested subjects was high, meaning nearly every enrolled student took the assessments.
On the TNReady assessments, proficiency rates in math and English language arts were on the lower side, while science and social studies showed somewhat higher shares of students reaching the proficient or above level. A parent considering this school should note that the state’s proficiency bar represents a specific academic standard, and these results give a sense of where the school’s overall performance sits relative to that measure. Because Smith County has only one school district, the neighbor comparison tool could not provide a relative position among county peers, so this school’s results stand without a local benchmark.
The district recently approved an operating budget for the 2024-25 school year without raising property taxes, a decision that matters for families weighing housing costs in the area. That budget included a salary increase for all employees and a step increase for teachers, as well as funding for a new school resource officer position and additional instructional technology. Separately, district leaders have discussed the possibility of building a new middle school facility, a topic that has come up over several years and was again raised in a 2024 budget work session. That project remains under consideration and has not been approved, so it is not a certainty for families planning ahead.
Carthage itself is a town with a stable, slow-growing population. Its housing stock is predominantly owner-occupied, and home values in the area are below the state median. The town’s economy draws on the county government, the local hospital, and the school district. There is no public transit system, and the downtown’s street life is limited to what a small rural county seat supports. Families will find a traditional courthouse square, river access at nearby Cordell Hull Lake, and a handful of National Register historic sites.
For a parent or resident, this is a school where academic proficiency in core subjects like math and reading is an area the data suggests is weaker, while science and social studies show a stronger performance. The student body is not especially diverse, and the district has been careful about avoiding a property tax increase even while raising staff pay and adding technology and safety positions. The potential for a new middle school building is a longer-term possibility that a family may want to track, but at present, the school operates in its existing facility. The overall picture is of a district that is managing its finances with restraint while trying to maintain and modestly improve its operations, set in a town whose character and pace of life have changed little over time.
See more original research from School Decision →