The top reported proficiency rate is 39% in English language arts. The lowest is 17% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Carrillo El
Carrillo Elementary is a prekindergarten through fifth-grade school in Houston, located on the east side of the city in a neighborhood marked by strong Spanish-language culture. The school's enrollment is small to moderate for its grade band, and the student body is predominantly Hispanic, with a substantial share qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch. This is a school serving a neighborhood with pronounced economic challenge and limited English proficiency among families.
Academic performance across tested grades shows proficiency rates in the lower range. In English language arts, third grade shows weaker results while fourth and fifth grades show modest improvement, with fifth-grade ELA reaching just under half of students meeting or exceeding standards. Math proficiency is similarly modest across all grades, clustering in the high thirties to low forties in terms of rate, though fifth graders do show slightly stronger average scale scores than younger students. Science, tested only in fifth grade, stands out as notably weak, with only a small fraction of fifth graders meeting standards. When aggregated across all tested subjects and grades, the school's overall proficiency index sits above the midpoint among districts in Harris County, a positioning that reflects meaningful gaps but not the lowest-performing schools in the area. The proficiency data likely reflects the school's student population: heavy concentration of students learning English and from families of limited economic means, both factors that correlate strongly with lower standardized assessment results nationwide.
The school sits within Houston ISD, which has been under state takeover since 2023. This governance change carries real consequences for families. An elected school board no longer exists; instead, appointed state managers govern the district, and local representation will not return until the district meets specific accountability criteria across special education, governance, and campus accountability outcomes. This is set to continue through at least 2027. The district has introduced a new standardized instructional model called the New Education System at some campuses, featuring scripted lessons, timed daily quizzes, longer school days, and tighter oversight; while Carrillo does not appear explicitly listed among NES schools, elements of this approach have spread across nearly all district campuses. The district also eliminated traditional librarian positions at many schools and repurposed libraries as spaces for students requiring behavioral support. These are substantial pedagogical and operational shifts that affect the day-to-day school experience.
Additionally, Houston ISD faced enrollment declines during the takeover period and in February 2026 the state-appointed board voted to close or consolidate twelve campuses after the 2025-26 school year. While Carrillo was not among the schools announced for closure, families in the school's area would want to monitor the situation closely given district-wide instability. The broader Houston region is growing rapidly, but the district itself is contracting, an unusual mismatch that reflects families' shifting choices, often toward charter schools or suburbs outside Houston ISD's boundaries.
The school's neighborhood is an east Houston location accessible by car. Housing costs in the 77023 zip code are substantially lower than Harris County's median, making it an affordable residential area, though home values have declined modestly. Rental availability is also relatively affordable. The neighborhood itself lacks the walkability of downtown or inner-loop Houston and is dependent on personal vehicles for most daily activity.
A parent considering Carrillo should understand that it is a school serving a low-income, largely Spanish-speaking community where standardized test outcomes are presently below district average. The school is embedded in a district undergoing profound structural and pedagogical change under state control, with no elected local accountability and an uncertain timeline for return to elected governance. Neither the school's immediate academic performance nor the broader district governance context presents obvious strength, but neither should be read as categorical failure; the question for a family is whether the school's actual academic trajectory, support infrastructure for English learners, and family comfort with the current district environment align with their needs. Direct conversation with the school and recent parent feedback would be important before enrolling.
See more original research from School Decision →