The top reported proficiency rate is 53% in English language arts. The lowest is 35% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Buffalo Elementary School
Buffalo Elementary School sits on Buffalo Creek Road in Kenova, a small riverfront city in Wayne County where the Ohio and Big Sandy rivers meet. The school serves pre-kindergarten through fifth grade as part of Wayne County Schools. Kenova itself was built as a railroad terminal town, and while the railroads that shaped it have receded, the community retains a quiet residential character within the Huntington-Ashland metropolitan area. The town has seen its population decline over the decades, and no major new housing developments or growth initiatives surfaced in publicly reported sources. What remains is a modest, close-knit place where civic life centers on landmarks like Dreamland Pool and the seasonally famous Pumpkin House.
The school's enrollment is moderate for an elementary building serving seven grade levels, and the student body is overwhelmingly white. A small number of students identify as multiracial, Black, or American Indian/Alaska Native. Free- and reduced-price lunch data was not available, and the same is true for English learner and special education counts, so the economic and special-population picture here is incomplete. Title I status was also not reported. A parent evaluating student support services may want to ask the school directly about how it serves economically disadvantaged students and those with individualized education plans, since those data points are absent from what was available.
On state assessments, Buffalo Elementary's results tell a mixed and grade-dependent story. In math, third graders posted a strong proficiency rate, fourth graders came in lower, and fifth graders dropped to a level where fewer than a third tested proficient. That downward slope across grade levels is a pattern a parent would want to understand before enrolling an older child. English language arts results were more even across grades, with fourth grade standing out as the strongest and third and fifth grade landing in a middling range. Science, tested only in fifth grade, showed a low proficiency rate. Participation was full across every tested grade, which means these results reflect the whole student body rather than a self-selected subset. No multi-year trend data was available, so there is no way to tell from the provided data whether these numbers represent a one-year dip or a persistent pattern. Average scale scores were also missing.
The school has no graduation rate, no advanced coursework, and no career or dual-credit pathways, which is expected for a building that ends at fifth grade. No program offerings were listed in the data, and civil-rights reporting on discipline, course access, staffing, and attendance was not provided. The district brief for Wayne County Schools turned up no recently reported changes that would be parent-relevant, so there is little to say about shifting priorities or new initiatives at the district level.
Housing in the school's zip code is affordable by almost any benchmark. Home values sit well below both the West Virginia state average and the national figure, and the estimated monthly mortgage cost is modest relative to typical incomes. Rent data was not available. For a family looking to buy, the cost of living near this school is low, and the price-to-income ratio suggests that homeownership is within reach for many households in the area. Whether that housing market draws families or reflects the area's long population decline is something the data alone cannot answer.
Buffalo Elementary appears to be a small-community school with strong early-grade math results that fade as students move toward upper elementary, steady but unspectacular reading performance, and a science result that raises questions about fifth-grade instruction. Families with younger children may find the early grades promising. Families with children approaching fourth or fifth grade may want to look into the drop in math proficiency and the low science score with the school before making a decision. The missing demographic and support data makes it harder to assess how the school serves its most vulnerable students, and filling that gap would help any parent get a fuller read on what this building offers.
See more original research from School Decision →