The top reported proficiency rate is 52% in Math. The lowest is 49% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Seth G. Haley School
Seth G. Haley School is a public elementary school in West Haven, Connecticut, serving students from pre-kindergarten through fourth grade. The school is situated in a mid-sized coastal city that is home to the University of New Haven and Yale's West Campus and sits between New Haven, Milford, and Orange.
The school enrolls students from across a diverse socioeconomic and ethnic spectrum. About half of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The student body is ethnically varied, with roughly equal numbers of white students and Hispanic students, along with meaningful shares of Black students and Asian students. Enrollment data for students with disabilities and English learners was not reported, so a parent may want to reach out to the school directly about these populations.
In the most recent testing year, Haley's proficiency results show two distinct grade patterns. Fourth graders performed at higher levels, particularly in math, where about three-fifths reached proficiency. Third graders showed lower proficiency, with just under half meeting the bar in both math and English language arts. Taking the school as a whole across both tested grades, proficiency rates center around the lower-to-mid range, placing the school above the midpoint among districts in the South Central Connecticut Planning Region. Growth patterns cannot be assessed from a single year of data, so a parent seeking to understand how Haley's academic trajectory is moving would need to look for historical results or speak with school leadership.
The broader West Haven School District has recently experienced significant change. The district ended state financial oversight in May 2025 after years under Connecticut's Municipal Accountability Review Board, following resolution of a fiscal crisis and a COVID-relief fund theft scandal. This return to local control, backed by audits and an improved bond rating, is a structural shift in district governance that bears on school funding and management. Additionally, the district has adopted Connecticut's state-mandated science-of-reading curriculum for kindergarten through third grade, emphasizing phonics and foundational decoding over older cueing methods. These shifts are now embedded in how early literacy is taught across the district's primary grades.
West Haven itself is actively pursuing redevelopment, with recent investments in shoreline restoration, a newly opened Metro-North commuter rail station within a transit-oriented development zone, and adaptive reuse of older buildings into housing. Housing values in the area are appreciating and rental costs are rising. The city has a mixed walkability profile; downtown and areas near the university and shoreline parks are notably walkable, while other neighborhoods are less so.
Seth G. Haley specifically serves the neighborhood schools across West Haven's early grades. The district's most recent facilities investment touched another elementary school: Washington Elementary School reopened in August 2025 as a fully rebuilt structure with modern systems, air conditioning, ADA compliance, and updated technology. Haley, located at 148 South Street, sits within a school system undergoing both operational renewal and community-wide growth.
See more original research from School Decision →