The top reported proficiency rate is 29% in English language arts. The lowest is 16% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Mary Mcguire School
Mary McGuire School is a regular public elementary school serving third through fifth graders in the Mt. Pleasant City School District, located in Mount Pleasant, the county seat of Isabella County, Michigan. The school sits on Crosslanes Street in a residential part of a city that blends college-town energy with a small-city feel. Central Michigan University anchors the community, and the Saginaw Chippewa Tribal Nation's Isabella Indian Reservation overlaps part of the city, which shapes the cultural makeup of the student body in ways a parent will notice.
The enrollment is moderate for a three-grade building, with the largest cohort in third grade and the smallest in fifth. A clear majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which tells you this is a school serving a population with real economic need. The racial and ethnic mix is predominantly white, with the next largest group being students of two or more races. American Indian and Alaska Native students make up the third-largest group, a reflection of the school's proximity to the reservation. Hispanic students represent a smaller but visible share, with tiny numbers of Black, Asian, and Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander students rounding out the population. Data on English learners and students with individualized education programs was not reported, so those populations are hard to characterize from the available information.
On Michigan's M-STEP assessments for the most recent school year, the results are genuinely soft. Math proficiency declines as students move up the grades, starting at a moderate level in third grade and falling to a lower level by fifth. English language arts follows a different pattern, with fifth grade posting the strongest result across all tested grades and subjects, while third and fourth grade sit lower. Fifth-grade science lands in the middle range, and fifth-grade social studies is the weakest result the school reports, with only a small fraction of tested students reaching proficiency. Taken together, the school's overall proficiency index places it in the bottom quartile relative to districts in Isabella County, below the county median and below every other district in the comparison set for which data was available. This is the single most important academic fact a parent should weigh. Participation rates were not reported, which limits what can be said about whether tested students represent the full enrolled population.
There is no graduation rate, chronic absenteeism figure, or course-access data to report, because this is an elementary school serving grades that do not produce those measures. The same applies to discipline and staffing data, which were not provided in the available sources. A parent wanting those details would need to contact the school or district directly. The district brief turned up little in the way of recent parent-relevant changes, so there is nothing concrete to relay on that front.
Mount Pleasant itself is a compact city with a historic downtown district separate from the CMU campus, a commercial corridor along Mission Street, and the Chippewa River running through town. The university is the dominant employer, with the Soaring Eagle Casino and Resort operated by the tribal nation in nearby Chippewa Township also a major regional employer. The city's population has seen a slight decline in recent estimates, and the poverty rate is elevated, likely influenced by the large student population. For a family considering the area, housing is relatively affordable compared with both state and national benchmarks, with home values well below the statewide typical and rents that are modest. Estimated monthly mortgage costs and rents are close enough that either path is feasible for a working family.
What this adds up to is an elementary school in an affordable, culturally layered college town, serving a student body with substantial economic need, and producing state test results that trail most of its county peers. A parent whose child thrives in a diverse, small-city public school setting may find the community appealing. The academic results, though, are a real consideration, and a parent may want to look into how the school and district are responding to those numbers before deciding.
See more original research from School Decision →