The top reported proficiency rate is 72% in Science. The lowest is 65% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Shelley School
Shelley School serves students from pre-kindergarten through sixth grade in American Fork, a city that has grown rapidly from a farming and trading center into a suburban hub within the Provo-Orem metropolitan area. The school is part of Alpine School District, which is in the process of a major reorganization. Voters approved a plan to split the district into three separate entities beginning in the 2027–28 school year, and under current proposed boundaries, American Fork would fall within the new Central district. This means families at Shelley can expect changes to governance, school boundaries, and potentially property tax structures in the near future, though the school itself will continue operating.
The student body is predominantly white, with a Hispanic population representing the next largest group and small shares of students who are Asian, Black, Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander, or of two or more races. A modest proportion of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The school serves a large enrollment for an elementary-level building, with classes that grow bigger at each successive grade level. Pre-kindergarten has a very small number of children, while the kindergarten through sixth-grade classes each hold a substantial group, with the largest enrollment in sixth grade.
State testing results, available for math, English language arts, and science, show a school performing well. Across the three tested subjects, Shelley’s overall proficiency level places it in the top quarter of schools when compared with other elementary schools within Utah County’s districts. This is a clear strength. The school’s proficiency in science is particularly strong, and its math and English results are also above the midpoint for the county. The state uses the RISE assessment for these grades, and families should be aware that Utah adjusted its cut scores for English language arts in a recent year, which can affect year-to-year comparisons, but the current results are solid.
Because Shelley serves only elementary grades, there is no graduation rate to report, and no data on chronic absenteeism was available in the source materials. The school did not report its counts of students with disabilities or English learners, so a parent who wants to understand how the school serves these populations may want to ask the school directly.
The school sits within the Alpine District, and the district itself is headquartered in American Fork. American Fork has a historic downtown core along Main Street, with a walking tour of sites like the old City Hall, but the broader built environment is suburban and car-oriented, with Interstate 15 running through the city. Major employers include American Fork Hospital, the school district itself, and a state facility, and the city has seen sustained population growth since the 1970s. Twenty-seven parks, the American Fork Library, a fitness center, and a FrontRunner commuter rail station that connects to Salt Lake City and Provo give the community amenities beyond the school.
Housing in the area carries a home value well above the national median, and rents are also high, reflecting the region’s rapid growth and demand. The ratio of home prices to income makes homeownership expensive relative to national averages, and monthly mortgage costs outpace typical rents, which gives a measure of the financial context families will face when choosing a home near the school.
Shelley School offers a strong academic foundation for elementary-aged students, with test results that compare favorably across the county. The coming district split introduces a period of transition that families should watch closely, but the school’s current performance and solid enrollment point to a stable, well-attended neighborhood school that serves a growing suburban community.
See more original research from School Decision →