The top reported proficiency rate is 47% in Math. The lowest is 40% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on New Creek Primary School
New Creek Primary School sits along New Creek School Road in a small, rural unincorporated community in Mineral County, West Virginia, roughly six miles south of Keyser on U.S. Route 50. The community grew up around a creek named for Peter New, an early settler, and once supported a tannery that has long since closed. Today New Creek has no concentrated commercial center, no traditional downtown, and limited walkability. Scattered residences and a firehall line the highway corridors. Residents tend to look north to Keyser, the county seat, for government services, shopping, parks, and the nearest college campus. The community is quiet and vehicle-oriented, and publicly reported sources describe it as stable or slowly changing, with no recent development projects identified.
The school serves pre-kindergarten through fourth grade and is a regular public school within Mineral County Schools. With an enrollment that is small even for a primary school, New Creek Primary operates at a scale where teachers and families likely know one another across grade levels. The student body is nearly entirely white, with a very small number of students identifying as Black or as two or more races. The school does not report free-or-reduced-price lunch data, special education counts, or English learner figures, so it is hard to gauge the full economic and support profile of the student population from what is available. A parent may want to ask the school directly about these indicators.
Because the school tops out at fourth grade, only third and fourth graders sit for the West Virginia General Summative Assessment, and only math and English language arts results are reported. The third grade math proficiency rate was solidly above where most schools land, while the fourth grade math rate dropped considerably, with fewer than half of tested students reaching proficiency. English language arts followed the opposite pattern: third grade was low, with less than a third of students proficient, while fourth grade landed at about half. Participation was full across every tested group. These results come from small testing cohorts, which means a handful of students moving in either direction can shift the picture sharply from year to year. The school does not report average scale scores, and no trend data across multiple years was available, so there is no way to tell from the provided data whether these results represent a stable pattern or year-to-year fluctuation. Science proficiency is not reported because the state tests science in grades five and eight, and New Creek Primary does not serve those grades.
There is no graduation rate, no AP or career pathway data, and no course catalog in the provided material, all of which is expected for a school serving only the early grades. The school also does not report discipline, attendance, staffing, or civil-rights data, so those dimensions of school climate and access are not visible here. No comparison fact-set was provided to position New Creek Primary against other schools in the county, so its relative standing among peers could not be assessed.
On the housing side, the New Creek ZIP code carries home values above the West Virginia statewide benchmark but well below the national figure, and values have drifted downward slightly over the past year. The price-to-income ratio sits below the national level, which points to a relatively affordable market by national standards, though current mortgage rates near six and a half percent shape what that affordability looks like in monthly terms. No rental data was available for the area. Publicly reported sources did not identify major employers within New Creek itself, and employment for residents likely centers on Keyser or other nearby towns.
For a family considering New Creek Primary, the school offers a very small early-grades setting in a quiet rural community close enough to Keyser for everyday needs. The academic picture is mixed and based on small tested groups, with a clear strength in third grade math and softer spots in third grade ELA and fourth grade math. Given how much is missing from the publicly available data, families would benefit from direct conversations with the school about instructional support, class sizes at each grade, and how the school prepares students for the transition into upper-elementary grades elsewhere in Mineral County Schools.
See more original research from School Decision →